Session Two, Round Five Results

Jan 31, 2007 15:18

Time for the results of Round Five! Two people are being voted off this week, so that we will be left with 6 participants.

No ties makes me happy. =)

The results )

round 5, neckerchief, session 2, results

Leave a comment

Comments 11

helgarr January 31 2007, 23:30:52 UTC
Oh, well,

Comments for #1.

And I'd like a banner to flaunt how much of an average iconmaker I am. ;D

Reply

fatesong January 31 2007, 23:48:16 UTC
Aw, you're not average, and you have your spiffy banners form here to prove it. xD

Crappy banner:

... )

Reply


tinkerbri January 31 2007, 23:41:09 UTC
Congrats to orlandogirl and _bluepinkle_! Well, I had fun. Comments for 4?

Reply

fatesong January 31 2007, 23:50:17 UTC
If you couldn't tell by all the times you got Mod's Choice, I really liked your icons. xD

I hope you participate again next session. =]

Comments for icon #4.

Least Favorite:
- It doesn't stand out, and I don't feel that the light texture at the bottom adds to it; it's just slapped on to fit the theme.

- first of all i really love the cropping. however, i don't like the way the texture was used; it doesn't compelement the picture and the bright colours look out of place on the some-what washed-out looks of the icon.

- The texture doesn't blend too well with the image and the colouring and the white dots are a bit distractive.

- i like how you used the texture,but the little dots of splatter seems out of place.i think it look better clean and smooth looking ^^

Reply

tinkerbri February 1 2007, 00:26:23 UTC
Aww thank you! I will be sure to participate next time. I lost inspiration this week, and I knew that I might not make it through. I guess I should take more time. Again, thanks! :D

Reply


orlandogirl January 31 2007, 23:43:46 UTC
oh wow thank you!^^ con grats _blurplinkle_!:)

and i love a banner please^^ please and thank you!

do i have any comments for #5?:)

Reply

fatesong February 1 2007, 00:09:42 UTC
Banner:

... )

Reply


thrift February 1 2007, 02:30:19 UTC
yay!! comments/critique for numéro six?

Reply

fatesong February 1 2007, 02:34:00 UTC
Comments for icon #6.

Least Favorite:
- The icon is too grainy and the Orihime's face and hair is not distinctive enough.

- the picture looks almost dirty with the...I guess...blotted texture.

Special Category:
- The overall composition idea is really great, and the swirl works well with the text.

- Definitely a creative and interesting swirl and text!

Reply


acting_chica February 1 2007, 15:02:12 UTC
Well, I still haven't won anything...
...but at least I'm still in.
That's the good part!
^_^

Comments for #2, please?

Reply

fatesong February 2 2007, 00:49:11 UTC
Comments for icon #2.

Least Favorite:
- The red stripe at the top kills my eyes. It distracts me and I think it clashes with the other colors.

Favorite:
- i really love the colors,its bright and shiny :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up