Session Three, Round Three Results

Apr 25, 2007 22:59

Tonight two people are leaving us.
That will leave us with 11 participants.

Who made it through? )

jubilli, session 3, round 3, results

Leave a comment

Comments 27

tinkerbri April 25 2007, 23:30:58 UTC
Congrats to those who remained! Comments for 9?

Reply

helgarr April 25 2007, 23:48:29 UTC
Critique:

Not a huge fan of the washedout-nuclear-skin colouring job; colouring of this icon just doesn't do it for me.

This is one of two real-person images, but it could have been spiffed up a bit more. It's not very contrasting. And I don't like the white pit at the top. My eye keeps going up there.

Reply


illeistic April 26 2007, 00:42:49 UTC
Omg, favourite again! ♥ I'd love a banner please, and my comments (for #5).

Reply

helgarr April 26 2007, 00:47:14 UTC
Good Comments:

Overall the icon is calm and cute, very well executed.

I'm not one for green, but this icon turned out wonderfully. :)

Reply

helgarr April 26 2007, 17:19:12 UTC
Don't know how you spell it. :)


... )

Reply

illeistic April 27 2007, 00:38:20 UTC
Favourite is the Canadian/British spelling. :D Favorite is American. I am Canadian, so I use the 'ou' spelling. (Other examples include color/colour, honor/honour, etc ;D)

Reply


raven353 April 26 2007, 01:02:58 UTC
grr, i could have tied with one more vote XP
comments for 8, por favor.
congrats to winners!

Reply

helgarr April 26 2007, 12:00:59 UTC
You had no comments.

Reply


hitomik April 26 2007, 02:46:40 UTC
Comments for #10 please.

Reply

helgarr April 26 2007, 12:02:17 UTC
Critique:

It's not that bad of an icon but the thing that disturbs me is that apart from the face and the hand I can't recognize what the rest of the icon is (effect? background? black/white?). If it is just random background then I think it doesn't fit with the image. Overall it also doesn't look finished, like there is something missing .. what exactly I can't say, maybe text.

This is another case of the texture overpowering the icon. The texture doesn't blend in well with the background image, and makes it really hard to tell what is going on in the icon. Also, maybe add text or something next time to spice it up, because i looks like you just took an image and dumped the texture on it.

Good Comments:

The crop and colouring are beautiful. Even without text or tiny text (none that I can see anyways) the icon looks complete. I love it. :D

The crop and colouring are beautiful. Even without text or tiny text (none that I can see anyways) the icon looks complete. I love it. :D

Reply


jigglypuff April 26 2007, 04:00:53 UTC
Yay! I made it to this round. XD;;; I'm still gonna watch the community though~ Good luck to everyone else.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up