Session Four Round Two Results

Jul 26, 2007 18:49

Finally! Tallying votes is hard work.
That will leave us with 14 participants.

Who made it through? )

session 4, kaien_kun, round 2, results

Leave a comment

Comments 22

shizukuchan July 26 2007, 19:06:24 UTC
ZOMG I'm still in!?!?
comments for 10 please :D

Reply

helgarr July 26 2007, 19:18:43 UTC
Least Favourite:

Very dark - not a whole lot of contrast.

Reason: The colours used look very dull and it looks almost blurry.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

helgarr July 27 2007, 22:59:06 UTC
Favourite/SC:

Pretty colouring.

Reason. the texture swirlyness matches the carefree theme of the icon. the coloring is very pretty, also

Reply


xspin July 26 2007, 19:37:54 UTC
Oooh I got positive votes. :D If there were any comments, can I see them for 12.

Reply

helgarr July 27 2007, 23:00:13 UTC
Favourite/SC:

I really love the coloring of this icon. And Blood Elves are awesome. XD

Reply


mangoninja July 26 2007, 20:59:41 UTC
Phew. I didn't think my icon would make it this round ><

11 please?

Reply

helgarr July 27 2007, 23:01:15 UTC
Least Favourite:

Defenatly hard this week, but I had to choose this one. The white bar of the text stands out way too much. It looks really bad and my eye keeps going there.

The text cutting through the image is rather unappealing and makes the icon boring.

Reply


inquisitorial July 26 2007, 21:00:23 UTC
Comments for #5 please?

Reply

helgarr July 27 2007, 23:02:17 UTC
Least Favourite:

The image isn't cut out very cleanly. The yellow dot at the top center is particularly distracting.

Reason: It doesn't look very creative.

Reason. i look at all the icons, and this one just...compared to the others, it's not the best. the coloring is odd, and there's that line on his face. you can't clearly see which texture was used, and the icon is still very plain with it.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up