Leave a comment

Comments 20

_inbetween_ July 17 2005, 17:24:24 UTC
A Snape fan disappointed by this? Huh. It was an ode to Snape! :( Of course the death scene was to throw you off the scent, it's just one big ruse, don't worry.

Reply

the_gwyllion July 17 2005, 17:43:00 UTC
Yeah...a bit I guess. I was so afraid to read that book when it arrived yesterday. Will have to take a while to get use to it all...

My poor Snapie....*pets* 8(

Reply

_inbetween_ July 17 2005, 18:35:17 UTC
He's not poor :( He's the big black hero. Just think of how it'll be all about him YET AGAIN in the next book.

Reply


the_gwyllion July 17 2005, 17:28:24 UTC
EEeeeee! Thank you! **Scrambles off to read more** I can never get enough of everyone's comments...83

Reply


crazychickencow July 17 2005, 17:33:18 UTC
Personally, I didn't like Tonks in this one. She was like my fave character in the last book, but now she reminds me too much of a Mary Sue. (Hmm. On an interesting note, JKR HAS said Remus is her fave character... o__O)

Harry pissed me off in the last one A LOT. But he pissed me off less in this, so YEHY.

And Harry got a lil' bit on my nerves on all his accusations and obssession with Draco.

"OMGZSQUEEITZLIKETOTALLYCANONNOWYAYJASLKDFJA;LSKDJ;FA!!!!"~with love, the H/D shippers.

XD!!!

Reply

the_gwyllion July 17 2005, 17:40:49 UTC
Lol! Yes! Tonks was AWESOME on the last one. I just couldn't help but feel bad for her in this book. *Pets her head* I think She and Lupin wouldlook cute together. *Wonders how old Tonks is..*

EEeeaack....I can't stand Draco....Lol! He makes me cringe. *Cringes* XD I especially got pissed when he stamped on poor Harry's face...though he did kinda deserved it for spying. Talk about violence there...whoa. And a notch of my dislike for him went down a few when I read the part where he was crying in the bathroom. Poor lil' dude....not! :D

Reply

crazychickencow July 17 2005, 17:56:53 UTC
EXACTLY. HOW OLD IS SHE. WUFUUUUH. That's gonna drive me up the wall...

Hehehe... I love Draco, but I have a weird, twisted sense of humour. So they say. My best friend is always saying I'm a mixture of Luna and Draco. Which is rather weird when you think about it. Like... a smoothie with horseradish or something. Yum. XD

My complaint with the book is that everyone is getting paired off into these little cookie-cutter romances. I personally felt like I was reading a fic...

Reply

the_gwyllion July 17 2005, 18:13:05 UTC
I personally felt like I was reading a fic...

OmehG you are so not alone! I had to look up a few times to tell myself that I'm actually reading the itself. Lol! And damn JKR for marrying my hot Bill off to that....that......Phlegm!!

*hacks*

Reply


deathangelgw July 17 2005, 18:22:39 UTC
I am soooooooo with you on the Bill and the Tonks things. I just...couldn't really stand the idea of Tonks/Remus! I couldn't! But then again, that's just me. And Bill and Fleur?! nonononono!! No happy French Veela bitch getting the hottie!!

My inner H/D is laughing in glee, my Snape lover is dying at the betrayal/angst, and I was sobbing when Dumbledore died. That's all I have to say about that. yeup...

And don't get me started on fanficcie feeling. I was seeing so many grammar and spelling errors, especially at the beginning, that I was starting to twitch!!! Site->Sight...COME ON! anyhoo, rant done. *glomps*

Reply


mokarran July 17 2005, 18:30:36 UTC
This book totatally killed changed everything that I had loved in Snarry. WHYWHYWHY?? I'm scared to read fics on them now

Really? Did you just like the fluffy OOC Snape one-shots? Personally, that's the only kind of Snarry fic that I think will suffer any damage. I think that HBP has given a lot for authors to work with, and an interesting challenge to the Snarry writers, which will hopefully result with more well-written, longer stories with more character depth and interaction. Of course, it will probably result in more of the darker stuff, too. But everyone has their little kinks, and that's fine with me.

And we all know that Dumbledore knew what he was doing the entire time. I refuse to believe Snape is a cold-blooded murderer... A lot of the recent entries at snape_potter have really confirmed what I had thought. People have some really good insight into the book... Severus Snape is still my favorite, no matter what.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up