Leave a comment

Comments 4

gothicdraco July 30 2007, 16:21:09 UTC
*puts up her hand*
I loved it too!

And it's good to know it reduced someone else to tears.

Reply


ioanna August 1 2007, 07:09:47 UTC
Why did you erase the essay? Damn it, I missed it! I mostly disliked the book but there were parts of it I really loved and I really don't think you were the only one who loved it! I felt alone in hating it, tons of people loved it!

Reply

the_intuitive August 1 2007, 19:50:05 UTC
Most of what I read online is people hating the book, picking it apart already. She had alot of people to please. There were alot of questions that she had to answer, some were left unanswered - seemingly unimportant to the author and more important to the fandom world - and some were answered in almost "glossed over" ways so as to appease the reader, but seemingly a forced connection or answer. I am hoping to read book 1 again. She has said from the beginning that the answers were technically ALL in book 1. I want to put that theory to the test.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

the_intuitive August 8 2007, 01:47:48 UTC
I agree. There was no way that anyone could meet the fans expectations on this book.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up