Critics...?

[the_mighty_dane]

so yeah im sitting here on a sunday afternoon talking to Vulpy when we hit the topic of critics.. now being from denmark and all and having had this whole free speech thing..... i still think that if some one claims the title thay should give constructive criticism and not just Dump on every thing and NEVER EVER review things that are not with in

Comments

[rachelsoma]

We were talking about this the other day on a comic forum - becuase large companies can and do infiltrate msg boards a lot of people will respond to a praise giving review by calling the critic a "plant" and accusing them of being soe one who works for the band/company/whatever.

On the message board I use there is a policy of positive reviews only and it's great! It means that people only review the stuff they really liked and want to tell everyone how good it is.

Why can't they do that wit everything else? If you hate a CD, dont talk abut it. If no one talks about it it wont sell copies and it people buy it and love it they'll talk about it and their friends will buy it.

Then everybody wins.

[__low__]

It's easy to criticise, I do it a lot.

It's harder to create something, from it's conception to it's birth!

Hope you're well, Dad!