R1-C02-Results
ELIMINATION
Because we had almost half of you guys skipping we are only eliminating 02 this week
simply_vm stardust111
simply_vm is unfortunately, eliminated from the competition.
stardust111 is down to one icon.
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
garnet_sunrise raisingrrrl
MOD'S CHOICE
nervous__girl stardust111
stardust111 - I just noticed when I was making banners that your icons exceeded 100x100 pixels, just make sure for future challenges that all your icons are 100x100. Other than that beautiful icon :-)
VOTING RESULTS
You can find your icon number here.
NEGATIVE VOTES
01: -5
02: -2
03: -2
05: -5
06: -1
07: -1
09: -1
12: -3
14: -3
15: -1
01 - too busy
01 - I can't find a focal point.
01 - It's too dark, and the texture doesn't seem to match the image.
01 - the texture makes the icon too "busy" and takes the focus away from the picture. The picture itself needs more sharpening.
01 - The check board background doesn't go well.
02 - tiny text too dark, seems out of place
02 - more could have been done with the colors, icon seems a bit dull.
03 - One bubble instead of two bubbles would work better.
03 - The colouring does not work, contrast is way too high.
05 - whatever is being drawn cannot be seen very well
05 - The crop seems to be done from an arbitrary place.
05 - I find the cropping of this one unsatisfactory. There is no real focal point.
05 - not fond of the cropping job, or the blob of light
05 - Needs some texture
06 - The background seems out of place.
07 - too much empty space, the colors are a bit dull and uninteresting.
09 - The icons seems "unfinished". If the idea was to make the icon simple, the coloring should have been more original.
12 - It's very dark and unclear.
12 - the icon is too sharp and the yellow frame doesn't fit the picture.
12 - frame is a bit oddly off centered, image is too sharpened.
14 - it's too big to use as an icon
14 - it's hard to tell what it's a picture of
14 - I can't see how this icon relates to "childhood", maybe I'm being picky, but the crop is off, I can't tell if it's a child or not!
15 - The colouring here makes me want to stare at the blue on the icon, my eye is not attracted to the yellow, more so the blue.
POSITIVE VOTES
02: +1
03: +1
04: +4
07: +2
11: +2
13: +3
14: +1
15: +2
02 - I tried to make one like this myself, but it didn't work for me! Great composition and lovely use of subtle colouring!
03 - i really like the concept of this icon, good composition and coloring.
04 - beautiful coloring! i love it.
04 - like the coloring and the text
04 - Very sweet with nice bright and simple colors
04 - I like the colouring and crop.
07 - It's simple, but works wonderfully.
07 - the concept is very original and I like the work with the blue and b&w coloring.
11 - unique, good subject choice
11 - relates to the overall theme and works nicely.
13 - makes me smile. good placement of text.
13 - This one made me laugh! Nice cropping, simple, and effective!
13 - very cute icon, nice use of yellow.
14 - Like the crispness of the colors
15 - I love the coloring.
15 - the cropping and the coloring are very good and match the childhood theme.