Comments | tigress35: Another HBP Theory

tigress35

Another HBP Theory

Jul 20, 2005 11:11

( Why Dumbledore Might Trust Snape )

Comments 6

bailunrui July 20 2005, 18:42:46 UTC

I like that theory!

sinisterf July 20 2005, 18:49:59 UTC

sounds probable

serafina20 July 20 2005, 19:02:37 UTC

I thought of that, but then decided that the Unbreakable Vow isn't really Dumbledore's style. It negates everything he believes in, like trusting people to make their own choices.

jollycynic July 20 2005, 19:25:40 UTC

I agree that the Unbreakable Vow doesn't seem very much like Dumbledore. Personally, I think it was a Snape/Lilly thing, despite alleged feelings towards mudbloods.

On the other hand, it explains things quite well.

aotearoagal July 21 2005, 06:08:12 UTC

Did you notice Snape saved Harry and was still teaching him even as Snape was fleeing the scene? althea posted awesomeness about this very topic.

tigress35 July 21 2005, 06:15:18 UTC

Ah yes, many have. I quite love it.