Thoughts on Harry Potter....

Oct 04, 2005 11:31

So this is just a little something that I was thinking about & wondering if anyone else noticed.

Defense Against the Dark ArtsThis is a position in the Harry Potter books that seems a bit cursed...no one after Quirrell keeps it for more than a year. (Even though JKR contradicts herself and has Dumbledore say that after he turned down Lord ( Read more... )

theory

Leave a comment

Comments 25

your_downfall October 4 2005, 13:11:10 UTC
I followed the link here from _tchp_, and I find your theory really interesting. I'm not sure if I agree yet or not, but I figured I'd drop you a line letting you know I'm thinking on it!

Reply

to_each_her_own October 4 2005, 13:19:39 UTC
:D It's some ramblings that popped into my head last night...but it made me curious if anyone else had ever made that connection before. *shrugs* Something to think about.

Reply


locknestra October 4 2005, 14:44:29 UTC
Your theory holds true for RP DADA Professors too.

Remus at TWL, and at Lumos... *shifty eyes*

Lycaon: I'M NOT EVIL!

Then you call the blood magic crap good?

Lycaon: Well, Thea and Damia

Do not do the same thing you do.

Lycaon: I'm not evil.

Killing is a good thing?

Lycaon: No! Really! I'm not evil!

Damien: *points to self* Evil.

Lycaon: See?

Your whole family is evil and you know it!

Lycaon and Damien: *Look at each other and shrug*

Reply

to_each_her_own October 4 2005, 17:00:26 UTC
hahahaha. I totally thought of Lycaon too. I almost put that as part of the whole thing, but I didn't...because I was like....what if no one gets that part. hahaha.

Trinity: *snogs Kay senseless*
Damia: *whistles innocently*

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

to_each_her_own October 5 2005, 07:23:55 UTC
Damia: *is the picture of innocence*

Reply


_southern_belle October 4 2005, 15:57:28 UTC
My lovely twin... your layout is gorgeous...

Reply

to_each_her_own October 4 2005, 17:01:45 UTC
I am in love with Delaney/Halvor. hahaha. If I change it....it would be to MORE DELANEY & HALVOR. lol.

Jewel is awesome.

Reply


lodessa October 4 2005, 16:42:28 UTC
That's a lovely and seemingly flawless theory

Reply

to_each_her_own October 4 2005, 17:07:10 UTC
Thanks...haha it would have been better if it had hit me BEFORE almost the end of the series, but ya know. haha. We can't control thoughts at 4am. =P

Reply

lodessa October 6 2005, 10:03:34 UTC
indeed... and well if you had it earlier the theory might have turned out ot be innacurate.

Reply


onezeronothing October 4 2005, 16:56:40 UTC
I also followed the link from tchp... First I wanted to say... Good God, we're in too many comms together. All of your "linked to" communities are ones I'm in. It was funny.

Also, I was going to point this out but the lexicon touched on it for a good few paragraphs. How long was Voldemort in Quirrel? Because, technically, if he was, in fact, part of Quirrel for three years and Dumbledore had a vague notion that it was him (I really do think that he's a manipulative bastard who faked his death)... then Rowling didn't contradict herself. No one held it for longer than a year after he said 'No' to Riddle.

Then Quirrel held the position for a year and went on the vacation where he picked up his little parasite.

Then Voldemort held the position for a few years.

Then Harry defeated him and they went back to one DADA teacher per year.

Now that I've taken up more space than necessary... what's your layout called?

Reply

to_each_her_own October 4 2005, 17:17:20 UTC
I think the layout is component....I dunno. haha. Jewel fierytempest coded it and did the graphics for it. It's of one of our RP pairings. ;)

Yeah the timeline thing was that Quirrell was fine for a year....went away for a year...then was there for a year before Harry's first year. So since he picked up Voldemort sometime during Harry's first year technically the same person has not held it for more than one year.

year 1- Quirrell
year 2- he was away and not teaching
year 3- changed to almost a different person
year 4 (Harry's first)- Quirrellmort.

XD totally. Also...yes...we are in a TON of communities together. I used to be over at hogwarts_elite too, but with my grandparents being really ill...I just can't guarantee to participate at the level they require. =P

And another thing....your Dory icon makes me extremely happy. Dory + Squishy = OTP. haha.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up