Top 10 Sci-Fi Characters

Jan 22, 2010 18:17


In working on this one I actually had a serious conflict or two when working with some of who I was going to fit into the actual top 10.  It wasn’t an easy task, outside of the top spots anyway. I mean I think I probably was able to rattle off my top 4 in a matter of seconds, but the rest of them were a bit of a challenge.  I mean what exactly puts ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 14

maximumfish January 25 2010, 22:37:49 UTC
Not disputing your list, as that would be sort of silly, but just to throw a few extra names into the mix:

Zaphod Beeblebrox - eccentric, heroically conceited genius, inventor of the pan galactic gargle blaster, former president of the galaxy, sole-survivor of the total-perspective vortex, and all around fun guy. Has three arms and two heads. TWO HEADS I say.

Paul Atreides - stilted voiceover and hardwood acting in David Lynch's movie version aside (and, let's face it, worse acting in the tv version), Paul/Maud'ib is a pretty epic sci-fi protagonist. First off he's incredibly intelligent, cunning to a near-machiavellian degree, and not above exploiting an entire indigenous people for his own personal revenge (at least partly). Paul evaded being the irrating goodguy who's good at all things and always right, despite being good at all things, always right, and the fucking messiah. Usually when messianic prophecies show up in anything, i reach for the remote or a different book, but Dune was fan-fucking-tastic, as was it's hero ( ... )

Reply

tom_gladius January 26 2010, 12:47:23 UTC
I may have to fall on my sword for the lack of Prime.

Cthulhu doesn't appear due to the fact that he hasn't been in any film or show that I can recall and if so it wasn't memorable enough for me to mention it here.

The "Alien" was more a creature, not a character and thus not really eligible. No lines and no personality, just instinct.

Max I think fits the bill of a personal favorite for you and an afterthought for me.

Honestly if I was including characters out of books then I probably would have put Paul in here but let's face it, no portrayal of him has been good. I know that you have nostalgia glasses for the David Lynch film but even an 80's Rock score won't put him in the list for me here.

Zaphod would have gotten more consideration had he been more like himself in the feature film.

Again right now though I feel like the Nostalgia Critic for not putting Optimus Prime in here. Damn!

Reply

maximumfish January 26 2010, 15:29:36 UTC
I didn't realize it was restricted to movie / television sci-fi characters; i definately wouldn't have put either movie Paul Atreides on there or any television or movie version of Zaphod Beeblebrox, and i pretty sure Cthulhu hasn't appeared in any movies other than that black and white silent movie they made (which i still want to see). He's been a pretty popular internet meme though...

And now some random Cthulhu pictures:


... )

Reply

tom_gladius January 26 2010, 17:03:51 UTC
I probably should have clarified that. I really wanted to keep it as tight as possible as far as the sources are concerned for a few reasons:

1) Pictures- I wanted to put visuals on here.
2) Familiarity- With the plethora of written sci-fi out there I really can't come close to knowing it all. I am sure there are tons of things that I don't know about that probably could have made this list.

Reply


What's happened to you?! Where's "Ripley"?!!!! Where's my sexy Cylon 7?!! anonymous January 26 2010, 19:17:08 UTC
From: Budniak, Michael ( ... )

Reply

Re: What's happened to you?! Where's "Ripley"?!!!! Where's my sexy Cylon 7?!! suspiria January 27 2010, 00:23:58 UTC
I cannot believe I'd never noticed the Han Solo/Mal similarities before. Wow.

Reply

Re: What's happened to you?! Where's "Ripley"?!!!! Where's my sexy Cylon 7?!! tom_gladius January 27 2010, 02:44:30 UTC
Kinda surprised you never noticed that before, especially because I know how much you love Firefly.

Reply

Re: What's happened to you?! Where's "Ripley"?!!!! Where's my sexy Cylon 7?!! suspiria January 27 2010, 20:32:19 UTC
Me, too! This was quite a revelation for me. I live in a household where Star Wars is serious business, AND I love Firefly. I'm just slow. =P

Reply


My personal 10 angusjack January 28 2010, 02:01:21 UTC
Mad ramblings with poor grammar follow ( ... )

Reply

Re: My personal 10 angusjack January 28 2010, 02:06:06 UTC
Actually scratch Luke from my 10 and replace it with Spiderman. Spidey does everything Luke does as a character but better.

Reply

Re: My personal 10 maximumfish January 28 2010, 19:28:40 UTC
I hate superman. If i lived in Metropolis, i'd be the guy trying to make kryptonite bullets in a basement lab with smoking beakers. I can't see Superman as an ideal, unless we're all striving to be torn out beefcake who run around in goofy spandex and stick our noses into other people's shit without anyone asking us to, simply because we can and because no one can stop us.

Okay, so i'll grant you that in the universe superman inhabits the division between good an evil is clear and damn near mathamatical, and that bad guys are so bad for the undiluted purpose of just being bad that we don't get too upset when superman BOOF!'s their faces in, instead of calling the police. And the police don't really seem to mind either. But then i would go on to argue that nothing meaningful can be derived from fiction so detached from reality and so simplistic, other than entertainment of course.

And on the entertainment front, i've never been able to get invested in faultless, invicible heroes.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up