Leave a comment

Comments 8

ptath03 February 24 2009, 19:49:31 UTC
I think that's pretty good. Very thoughtful. The beginnings of a Gryfindor Guilt Trip. I really wish Snape had lived...

Reply

brookiki March 1 2009, 04:20:53 UTC
Heh, I was so impressed by your icon that I didn't notice your name.

I'm annoyed about Snape dying, not just because I liked the character, but I feel like it cheated us out of so much interesting stuff. It's almost like Snape took the coward's way out by letting Voldemort kill him, rather than answering for everything after the fact.

Reply


idreamofdraco February 25 2009, 00:14:22 UTC
I like it. It brings up issues JKR completely skipped over in her happy epilogue.

Also, I think everyone needs a beta, even if only for a second set of eyes.

Reply

brookiki March 1 2009, 04:22:04 UTC
Betas are really great for people like me, who tend to fill in the blanks on their typos and not catch their mistakes.

All in all, the epilogue was a huge letdown to me. As someone pointed out, it brought in next-gen characters, but I'd rather have had more closure on the existing ones.

Reply

idreamofdraco March 1 2009, 05:22:31 UTC
I know a lot of people hated Deathly Hallows and/or the epilogue, but I actually really liked both. I know Harry probably would have had some serious emotional issues when the war was over, after all these people dying and basically being raised by Dumbledore to die for the world, but for the basic premise of the story, the ending was perfect, in my opinion. Of course, Ginny totally should have married Draco instead of getting back together with Harry, but that's why I read fan fic, right? ;D

Reply


jack_infinitude February 25 2009, 01:59:51 UTC
I like it!

Reply

brookiki March 1 2009, 04:22:31 UTC
Thanks!

I need to write some Tony/McGee stuff for you, as your graduation present. I have a while on that, though, right?

Reply

jack_infinitude March 4 2009, 02:08:27 UTC
That would be the best graduation present ever.

Haha, you have about three months! :D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up