Round 17 - Challenge 01 - Voting

[absolutelybatty]

ROUND 17 - CHALLENGE 01 VOTING - SHINE

Welcome to Round 17, guys! And what an impressive turn out we've had! I'm really excited to get started! Just an fyi to all new participants (and old), we have several resources to help you out with voting. They are linked in the post below, but I'll just run through them now: a deconstruction of our voting

Comments

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

It is a pretty good bunch this go around so I understand where you're coming from!

Your second concrit vote is fine actually, but if I could get you to rephrase your first one, that would be awesome. What you've pointed out in the icon is fine, but a vocabulary that's a little less harsh in terms of your description of the textures effects would be great.

Thank you so much!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

That's excellent! Thank you very much!

And yes, you can if you like. We've had participants do it in the past.

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Nah, you did fine. If you do get a chance to come back and expand on your first concrit vote a little more though, that would be perfect. Maybe offer some solutions to toning down the over-brightening? Just to make it more helpful to the person receiving it!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Oh, excellent! Thank you so much for editing!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

HI, thank you for voting! If you have a chance to come back and expand on your concrit votes, that would be excellent. Keep in mind, these are not negative votes. While you should identify problem areas in the icon you should also try to provide ideas on how to fix these areas. It doesn't need to be long, just a sentence or so, and there are lots of guides linked above if you need any help. Thank you!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Hi, thank you for voting! If I could get you to come back and expand upon your concrit votes, that would be excellent. It just needs to be a sentence or two maybe pointing out where the saturation or contrast is too high, why that might be an issue you'd point out, and perhaps how to eliminate those issue in future icons. There are several guides linked above that should help you out if you need it. Thank you!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

No worries! Just do the best you can and if there are any issues with word choice or anything, I'll let you know. Or if you want to ask first, just drop me a comment, and I'll get back to you as soon as I can.

Thank you for editing!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

Hi, thank you for voting! You've got some really nice concrit votes shaping up there, but if I could get you to come back and expand upon them, that would be awesome. If you could point out, perhaps, where the icons are too sharp and why that might be an issue and maybe offers some solutions there. And if you could detail a little more about the clock as well, that would be really useful for the person receiving your votes. There are lots of guides linked above if you need any help! Thank you!

[anonymous]

[absolutelybatty]

It's actually easier for me if you just reply to my comment with just the parts that need to be edited. So just leave the new concrit votes in a reply to this comment, please. Thank you!