Comments | ultimate_lims: LIMS Challenge 3: RESULTS

miss_sarac in ultimate_lims

LIMS Challenge 3: RESULTS

Mar 24, 2006 16:15

First, I'd just like to thank those of you who actually follow the rules. Believe me, it makes this a LOT easier.

Now unfortunately it's time to say goodbye to six more people:

( Read more... )

challenge 3

Comments 23

zerographic March 24 2006, 23:45:03 UTC

crazydiamond_ I really loved the effect you used on the image. It makes it look like a lovely painting. Also loved the addition of the eye make-up. I'm sorry to see that one go.

I'm really proud of not getting any votes this week. I think this conpetition has pushed me. The icon I submitted is on of the best I've ever done. I'm having a lot of fun with this!

crazydiamond_ March 25 2006, 07:55:30 UTC

Thanks-- frankly, I'm a bit surprised, too. There were some I felt were SLAMMIN' ugly and their makers are still in, so... [shrug] Who knows what people will decide they hate? Ah, well :)

sifted March 25 2006, 00:49:39 UTC

ah, man. that sucks. but oh well. all the entries were great!

could i please see the comments for my icon/#24, thanks.

ctofine March 25 2006, 01:31:36 UTC

Holy icons, batman. People's Choice? Is it horrid to admit that I did this one at the speed of light? Although it was one of those that once you get going it just falls together.

Thank you! So many absolutely gorgeous icons in this round!

keeperofthekeys March 25 2006, 01:32:47 UTC

I posted a request for comments on the last post, but because I was on spring break, I didn't get the request in until some time after the challenge ended. Since I was booted off last week, I would really like to know why, if you wouldn't mind looking back to the request I posted there. Thank you.

miss_sarac March 25 2006, 02:22:22 UTC

sure. Ill get those to you tonight

keeperofthekeys March 25 2006, 02:36:49 UTC

:)

Thank you!

(The comment has been removed)

miss_sarac March 25 2006, 02:21:13 UTC

At first I thought you were joking, but then I realized that you're not, so I'll word this as nicely as I possibly can.

No people did not make a mistake. I read over the comments to make sure of just that. The reasons given for voting that icon off were sound. And the first one was NOT loads of peoples favorite, just one. Myself & the other mod feel that these icons were the ones that deserved (for lack of a better word) to be voted off.

I'd ask you though what standards are you voting by? Do you not look at whether an icon is oversharpened or not?