FLMPotD

Mar 31, 2011 13:10

Compute \sum_{k=0}^n (-1)^k \binom{n}{k}/(k+1).

flmpotd

Leave a comment

Comments 5

darkerline March 31 2011, 23:46:38 UTC
It turns out Wolfram|Alpha can do this one.

Reply


sergeibernstein April 1 2011, 00:14:09 UTC
Ooh. An FLMPotD that I can solve. :-D

Reply


limitedcake April 1 2011, 13:26:24 UTC
That was fun!

Reply


oxeador April 3 2011, 05:38:30 UTC
For once I am allowing you to use the letter L.

I solved it by taking the binomial formula and integrating it. Is there a simple, combinatorial argument?

Reply

ultrawaffle April 3 2011, 21:31:09 UTC
I was hoping someone would come up with a nice combinatorial argument! I know of two ways of doing it. The simplest way is to rewrite \binom{n}{k}/(k+1) as \binom{n+1}{k+1}/(n+1) and using the binomial theorem (since the denominators no longer depend on k). You can turn this into a combinatorial argument, but it seems kind of clunky to me and I don't see how to make it elegant. The other way, which sounds like basically the way you did it, is how I originally came across this. I was idly thinking about things like "if you take n random numbers (with respect to some distribution), what is the expected value of the largest one?" This sum came out of doing an integral to compute the following: if you pick n numbers in [1,\infty) with respect to the probability density function 1/x^2, what is the probability that the last one is the largest of them? In this formulation, of course, the answer is obvious.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up