[Beiste would feel bad leaving anyone out, so anybody who doesn't find a personalized present outside their door is getting a warm pair of gloves and a hat.]
((In no particular order:
Kurt:
A pair of Gucci sunglassesSantana: A book filled with handwritten quotes along
these linesPuck:
A Space Invaders guitar strapRachel:
A sweater deer (she may have misheard someone)
Poland: Some Polish sausages and homemade buns
Dave:
A red sunglasses case and a note saying Let's see those eyes, kiddo.
Terezi:
This revolutionary bookDean:
This apronQuinn:
Some punk earrings and
pink headband with a note saying Be happy either way, okay?
Yuu:
Some barbells and a note that says Preparation for when fighting back is the only option.
Nepeta:
Catfeet twinsJames and Sirius: A note saying Come talk to me and I'll give you your real present.