01-07: Voting
Hell yeah everyone submitted (and on time, to boot!) to our first semi-finals!
voting information
challenge 01-07
04 out of 04 participants have submitted.
skips None
defaults None
withdrawals None
voting rules
• Anyone can vote. You do not have to be a participant to vote! Voting is not required, but the more votes we receive, the more accurate the results will be. So please vote! It only takes a few minutes.
• Do not vote for your own icon or ask anyone to vote for you.
• You will be voting for two(2) icons of lesser quality and one (1) favourite icon.
Please base your votes on overall quality of the icon (ie texture usage, image quality, crop, typography etc...) and not based on how much you like the character in the icon. Critiques for your the icons you feel are of lesser quality and should be eliminated are mandatory. Critiques for your favourite icons are optional, but greatly encouraged!
As a general rule, aim for a 10+ word critique.
examples of good criticism
## - The character in this icon is over-sharpened, so the lines of their hair appears jaggy.
## - The textures you used overpower the character in this icon.
## - I really like the angle of the crop in this icon. It's cute, and draws your attention to the character's face.
examples of bad criticism
## - This icon is ugly.
## - I don't like the character in this icon.
• Please use the provided form for voting:
Eliminations
#00 e - critique here (mandatory)
#00 e - critique here (mandatory)
Favourite icons
#00 f - critique here (optional)
Optional critiques
#00 o - critique here. Does not count as a vote, but may be helpful to the icon maker. You can make as many of these as you want.
• Make sure to double-check your votes, as it's easy to mix up numbers!
1
2
3
4
Voting will end in 24 hours on Saturday, October 2nd at 11:00 PM PST.
voting information
challenge 01-07
04 out of 04 participants have submitted.
skips None
defaults None
withdrawals None
voting rules
• Anyone can vote. You do not have to be a participant to vote! Voting is not required, but the more votes we receive, the more accurate the results will be. So please vote! It only takes a few minutes.
• Do not vote for your own icon or ask anyone to vote for you.
• You will be voting for two(2) icons of lesser quality and one (1) favourite icon.
Please base your votes on overall quality of the icon (ie texture usage, image quality, crop, typography etc...) and not based on how much you like the character in the icon. Critiques for your the icons you feel are of lesser quality and should be eliminated are mandatory. Critiques for your favourite icons are optional, but greatly encouraged!
As a general rule, aim for a 10+ word critique.
examples of good criticism
## - The character in this icon is over-sharpened, so the lines of their hair appears jaggy.
## - The textures you used overpower the character in this icon.
## - I really like the angle of the crop in this icon. It's cute, and draws your attention to the character's face.
examples of bad criticism
## - This icon is ugly.
## - I don't like the character in this icon.
• Please use the provided form for voting:
Eliminations
#00 e - critique here (mandatory)
#00 e - critique here (mandatory)
Favourite icons
#00 f - critique here (optional)
Optional critiques
#00 o - critique here. Does not count as a vote, but may be helpful to the icon maker. You can make as many of these as you want.
• Make sure to double-check your votes, as it's easy to mix up numbers!
1
2
3
4
Voting will end in 24 hours on Saturday, October 2nd at 11:00 PM PST.