Comments | we_trust_snape: Attention members: Question to answer

ladystrange2000 in we_trust_snape

Attention members: Question to answer

Jul 17, 2007 18:43

Should we stop accepting new members after 7/21/07?

And since I don't want this to be spoilery, I'll leave it at that.

Comments 12

snapefantasy July 17 2007, 22:49:53 UTC

I think it should depend on what questions are answered in the book. If things are left...unsorted, it would be a nice debate comm.

wwowie July 17 2007, 23:16:49 UTC

I have friends who are planning to read the books but have yet to even read the first one! What if someone doesn't get to the last one until next year?

(Just playing devil's advocate here. :) )

ladystrange2000 July 17 2007, 23:42:39 UTC

But after Saturday the matter will be settled, even if new fans join the fandom.

wwowie July 18 2007, 00:35:32 UTC

very true :)

wickedmommy July 18 2007, 01:30:57 UTC

I think if we find out that Snape was good all along (which I firmly believe) We could always change the name of the comm to "Ha Ha We were right".

ladystrange2000 July 18 2007, 01:32:26 UTC

I've always thought WTS could stand for "We Toldya So!" ;)

wickedmommy July 18 2007, 01:33:57 UTC

See now that is just much classier. I vote for WTS!

cmwinters July 18 2007, 05:21:13 UTC

As I haven't read any of the spoilers and remain blissfully ignorant, I do not feel entirely capable of weighing in on a matter of such import until such time as I have all the information in front of me.

Bearing that in mind, I shall comment on 7/22/07, or thereabouts.

lifegirl July 18 2007, 10:18:07 UTC

Mh ... good question.
But I think, after the 21.07.2007, we hopefully will be the ones who knew better. Everyone can say afterwards that they knew and so on.
So I think - no, we shouldn't accept new members after that significant date.

carebear72884 July 18 2007, 14:03:41 UTC

I agree, I like the idea that this is an elite group of people who support Snape until the end. Even if someone hasn't read the books, like mentioned above, they will know the over all story. Kind of like people who have never watched Star Wars know that Darth Vater is Luke's father. Its just stuff you know.