Comments | winslet_lims: voting challenge two

motorized in winslet_lims

voting challenge two

Mar 18, 2009 10:12

Hey guys, I'm so sorry that this is late but I've been bedridden with the flu for the last week. Voting will stay up for the next couple of days and then we will start challenge 3 on time.

SKIPPING: motorized electrical_s stam_fan17 driveshaft108

VOTING RULES- Don't vote for or against yourself, or ask other people to vote for or against you ( Read more... )

challenge two, round one, voting

Comments 11

quiddity_ March 17 2009, 23:47:09 UTC

LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
04 - the BRIGHT neon blue is really unnatural, especially in her hair. would've been nice without the inset.
08 - the not-black and white coloring is disconcerting. the cutout is a bit jagged around kate's shoulder.
06 - too dark. the blue cloud/texture doesn't look right over her arm. overall, icon needs more contrast

FAVORITE ICONS
07 - good coloring
05 - fantastic use of negative space and contrast. the text though... ugh. different/more imaginative text or a brush or *something* would've been more preferable to
bad
eno
ugh
=\

allllure March 18 2009, 00:14:22 UTC

LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
#08 - it's very sloppy looking, and the coloring doesn't work.
#04 - the colored portion is overly yellow and blue, and just too contrasted.
#06 - the icon is too dark and the texture doesn't fit.

FAVORITE ICONS
#10 - love how vivid the coloring is.
#02 - love how simple looking it is and how they used both pictures.

setentpet March 18 2009, 00:37:48 UTC

oh sorry to hear about the flu, that sucks!

LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
#10 - skin tone is way too orange.
#9 - the coloring is very nice but the skin appears to be a little blotchy.
#11 - the black and white is nice but the face appears to be a little pixilated.

FAVORITE ICONS
#4 - the coloring is very nice. really like the black and white with the colored kate circle, makes it pop out.
#7 - nice coloring and crop.

ugh........it was hard deciding.

hermionesparkle March 18 2009, 01:21:52 UTC

LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
##6 - the coloring makes the image washed out and blurry looking
##8 - contrast is to high
##10 - the crop is not appealing

FAVORITE ICONS
##3 - great crop and text placement
##7 - beautiful coloring

goodbye_anymore March 18 2009, 04:02:33 UTC

LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
04 - the icon has too much going on. the light textures are badly placed
08 - the coloring is too washed out on the closer pic and too bright on the other
10 - the crop is too close, the coloring too orange

FAVORITE ICONS
03 - nice coloring, good use of text
07 - good crop, crisp coloring