Results LIMS Challenge 8

May 02, 2010 22:20

Great turnout for Lims Challenge 8! Unfortunately 1 participant will be leaving us tonight.


ELIMINATIONS

VOTED OFF

by flame_eternel (-5)

CONGRATULATIONS!

FAVORITE ICON + BANNER

by lastyearswishes (+2) » Click to Save your Banner !

MOVING ON TO NEXT ROUND
17tvfreek
beybey16510
lastyearswishes
narniacmr
rhye

narniacmr You do not have a skip anymore as explained in the Main Post about how LIMS works: Once we've reached the last five contestants your skips will be of no use to make the competition fairier.

VOTING TALLIES!

Here's the tally. Remember we're picking 3 least favorites and 1 favorite. Therefore, a negative (-) denotes how many people voted against your icon and a plus (+) denotes how many people voted your icon their favorit, zero (0) means you got neither or that they anuled each other out. So if you have a + point, pat yourself on the back!

Lims Challenge 8: To Do List

01
02
03
04









05
06
07
08





-
-

01: -5 + 0 = -5
02: -2 + 2 = 0
03: -1 + 1 = 0
04: -1 + 3 = 2
05: -2 + 0 = -2
06: -1 + 0 = -1

+ POSITIVE VOTING COMMENTS +

#02 -- I really like the coloring on Harry in this icon. The text on the to do list is clear and easy to read.
#02 -- I just like everything about it, to be perfectly honest.

#03 -- Gorgeous use of text, the check box looks perfect.

#04 -- lol! It made me laugh, especially the last bit. Plus the composition and colouring are great and fit the image really well.
#04 -- I love how the picture made Voldemort look like he was thinking. Plus it made me laugh out loud. ^^
#04 -- The images fits well with the To Do list, it looks like he's thinking about the next thing he has to do. lol Nice composition.

- NEGATIVE VOTING COMMENTS -

» Don't take these comments as mean pointless critics, they could help you make a better icon for the next challenge!

#01 -- The way the text has been added over the picture makes the text very difficult to read. The multiple colours of text likewise make it non-cohesive and hard to read. The blurring behind Snape seems to have been done in a hurry. Especially in the upper right the edges of the blurred region are obvious. The overall coloring of the background image is very nice, though.
#01 -- The text is kind of hard to read and seems kind of random on the icon.
#01 -- Great icon, so very true. However the text is a little unreadable over his hand. Maybe a different colour or font would have looked better.
#01 -- The lettering is too big and overlaps the photo too much.
#01 -- I love the text but the placement and the colors chosen make it kind of difficult to read. Also, the coloring used really washes out the image.

#02 -- The colouring is great but I think the text is a little difficult to read. Perhaps if there was less, it seems a little too close together maybe.
#02 -- The image of Harry seems a bit blurry while the text is a bit pixelized. I love the little scroll for the To Do list thought.

#03 -- The black border on the icon really stands out especially against the grey of the bottom half of the icon, and it draws too much attention from the icon. The crop on the top half is not very inventive. The coloring is nice, though.

#04 -- The coloring/black bg make Voldemort look a bit overly washed out and the text is overpowering.

#05 -- The coloring used is unflattering, moslty on his forehead.
#05 -- The text is a bit pixelized.

#06 -- The coloring of the lettering doesn't go well with the background coloring of the icon. I would have made the background red with the white letters accenting it.

It's farfadine's turn to do the Nomination for the winning icon. (with the Noms for Week 246 in a couple of days. There's a HUGE lack of entries in Week 246 by the way, please enter!)

lims results

Previous post Next post
Up