Weekly Card

Feb 02, 2009 08:52

Leave a comment

Comments 5

chrysologus400 February 3 2009, 03:48:02 UTC
Based on Shards and Conflux, I would say ability 2 should actually gain her counters. The white Shards Planeswalker is CRAZY powerful, as is Nicol Bolas. They seem to push the limits of how powerful cards are allowed to be.

Reply

wsushutin February 3 2009, 07:26:11 UTC
There's only one planeswalker that has two abilities that gain counters.

Reply

chrysologus400 February 3 2009, 15:47:31 UTC
Oh. Then apparently Elspeth is just broken.

Reply


murmur000 February 4 2009, 18:36:51 UTC
i think the +1 ability could be more flavorful. maybe it could also draw you a card-like, she steals one from your opponent and gives it to you.

overall, i think it could actually be a lot more powerful. it's certainly not as good as sarkhan vol or ajani vengeant who are easier to cast. the -1 ability should be better. maybe instead of eot, she could give vigilance and shroud to all creatures with +1/+1 counters on them. it might have to be -2 instead. also, maybe she should make them unblockable instead of giving them vigilance for flavor reasons, although maybe that's too powerful.

Reply

wsushutin February 5 2009, 03:53:23 UTC
Yeah, I'm not very good with planeswalkers. I'll just have to try and stay away from making any more of them. Looking back I'm not really sure what the plan was, maybe I was in a hurry? I don't know. It's not a very good card.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up