K Cassies will boycott
Trans: @theyoungestmin
**'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ' is very famous fancafe in Korea. This fancafe existed since tvxq debut, never waver once. In the past, 5 members left the mentions for fans. So many Cassiopeia wanted to join TCT.**
**And DBDN, Poplez, UERUBI, DC, etc.. Many fansites are reaching similar decisions as I've told before..**
**I don't want to tell this. So I didn't answer the questions about the situation in Korea for several days. But I think international fans have to know the situation in Korea and they have the right to know. There is a proverb in Korea. "Palms never hide the sky."**
**Some of you will attack me again. But it is the reality. Some of you also think Korean fans are arrogant. But if many Korean fans boycott TVXQ as duo, they never work in even overseas. Because they don't make profits, SM will never support them. If so, some of you will think they'll work in overseas. But it'll be impossible. SM is not charity. SM is the company to seek making profits. For instance, CSJH... they were popular in overseas but they weren't in Korea. Have you ever heard about CSJH's new album?**
**I don't want to impose to stand one side. But The way things look, the possiblity of reunion is remote. To cover the truth is not the best way. Sometimes we need a cool-headed assessment of the situation. I want to tell you this.**
This is the official position of 'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ' about TVXQ as a duo.
Hello. This is the sysop of 'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ'(TCT). After passing the 2010 that was harder we expected but felt fresh, it was to come the New Year. I wish all of you a Happy New Year.
And as a sysop, I'm very sorry to announce the notice like today, to many our members with TCT for 7 years.
If it's possible to be with all of you, it may be better. Because TCT that held barely under the big justification of '5 each member are the TVXQ' lost even the justification, I became to announce the official notice.
In fact, through last official notice, we appeared the position of our managers and you'll already predict the major opinion. So it's not surprised and not brandnew, predeterminate thing.
In the early of December.
Jung Yunho & Shim Changmin announced to start to work as TVXQ. So TCT lost the identity of the fancafe of TVXQ to consists of 5 members. Because from now TVXQ became to call just Yunho & Changmin officially.
Of course, because SM & HM monopolize the name of TVXQ, Homin are not enough to get the authenticity of 'the real TVXQ' from the public and other 3 members.
Because the authenticity of TVXQ naturally establish to fulfill the requirements, TVXQ is a boy band to be made up with Yunho, Jaejoong, Yuchun, Junsu, Changmin and they are ultimately acceptable appearance to the public including other members and fans.
Yunho & Changmin don't secure the TVXQ's authenticity as they just announced to use the name of TVXQ one-sidedly without an agreement of other members to have the equal right and to be against the fans' opinion.
But now they announced 'the real TVXQ is just two of us' to use the word of 'the authenticity'. And SM also can't deny to rule out other members from the group of TVXQ.
There was a group to have a similar process to break up but we've never seen to announce to use the group's name just like this. Because they knew what the minimum consideration is to other members and their fans.
HM could work not to use the name as much as you like as JYJ.
And they clearly knew to exist other members' fans in TVXQ's fandom. If so, at least, they had to ask to be excused as a matter of courtesy and that is the proprieties to fans who have support for 7 years.
But they didn't express the words of sorriness
and insisted on aery justification like authenticity.. We cannot help thinking to ignore us without a consideration. Because of this, there are so many fans to feel disappointment and despondency.
And that is a natural result.
Besides, if they remembered the rumors that SM made the rotation of TVXQ's member, they feel disappointment more about the announcement.
Some of you remember the contents of documents to agree between SM and members. In the document, there was a desperation to keep their members although they had an unfair contract for 13years.
Some of Homin fans distorted just the part of '13 years' in the document. So we are struck dumb with amazement.
However, at those times, absolutely all members, and their parents who asked to help to keep the TVXQ, and the fans who worked to keep members without sleeping at united fansite remembered the core of the documents.
'TVXQ means to be made up with Jung Yunho, Kim Jaejoong, Park Yuchun, Kim Junsu, Shim Changmin. And the worth and the influence that TVXQ has are created by 5 members. So if one of them is ruled out or added, that wouldn't be TVXQ.'
And emphasizing to leave the document to have legal force by concert between SM & members, their parents including Yunho's father to ask to post the contents as above knew more especially.
And many fans & other members made to feel some kinds of despondency to announce that they use the name of TVXQ. If fans use the word like sense of betrayal, it is right like this case.
Of course, when we faced to meet a situation hard to tell that JYJ came out from SM and HM left, SM and HM overused the word of 'betrayal' with asserting that JYJ came out because of 'cosmetic'
But all of TVXQ's fandom expressed to give the support the opinion of JYJ and we've criticized to use [SM unfair contract] as the front of sentence and now we've continued to criticize about SM. It means the claim of SM and HM wouldn't accept to the fandom.
Why does it happen? Is it because there're much more JYJ fans in this fandom?
If there is person to answer 'yes', he or she is never disqualified to say 'the truth' of 'the justice'.
If they have the belief about their claim, in this fandom, they confidently protested that SM didn't give members as an unfair treatment and they had to suggest the basis whoever could be acceptable.
But some of HM fans stole ex-DNBN's domain and then posted something to blame JYJ to come out from SM. We could find the prerequisite 'SM also had a mistake'. It was because some of HM fans also couldn't claim like 'SM is fair and reliable group.'
When they worked together, almost of fans didn't trust SM
and because of this, the rumor of rotation could have risen massively.
Especially, the fandom of Yunho to take the initiative others at those times never forget that you were the person to protest about distrust and injustice against SM strongly.
With some of HM's fansite as the central figure, they clouded the essence of an unfair contract and empower to SM as they posted something to distort about JYJ and to make a personal attack on JYJ is not different to betray for themselves.
And now the court accepted JYJ's petition because there's a legal problem. So from the court, JYJ received the ruling like this.
'when the trial is in the march, SM never interrupts their independent work'
And FTC ordered the 'Warning' about unfair contracts against SM. And then SM rectifies their mistake after it accepted.
These facts are real examples that their opinions like 'we never had unfair contracts' was not dishonorable in front of 'the sternness of the truth' as they always told.
Through the official interview, JYJ defined that they considered to come out from SM And before a year from the trial was raised by media. And it was not only because of an unfair contract and they felt humane disappointments from SM. It affected to come out very much.
And many fans already knew these circumstances before the trial was raised. Because of that, many fans not to understand Homin to remain SM spoke in a fierce tone their mind to feel sense of betrayal.
But some of Homin fans unconvincingly protest that JYJ accused Homin of being betrayers. We knew 'the mention to distort the 625 meeting' is the only basis. And we heard that it'll post the real fact to arrange about it.
But definite things are that many fans used the word, 'betrayal', is because they basically distrust SM. And before a year from the trial was raised by media, many fans felt betrayed from Homin because they already knew that they wanted to come out from SM.
There are multiple reasons to affect to them. Many fans' opinion didn't make suddenly just by JYJ's conspiracy as their(Homin fans' opinion) opinion.
On the contrary, everyone knew that HM practically criticized JYJ through the official documents and announcement to express their positions. Furthermore, people close to HM also have criticized JYJ persistingly. It is simply that they seriously diminished the images of JYJ as entertainers.
On the other other Hand, they told that they left place for that JYJ will turn back to SM. No one could believe the veracity of their opinion.
If they really want to reunion, how they have criticized JYJ persistingly for more one and half years.
And SM had the history that SM made the troubles with entertainers to belong to them and then they had experiences to lose a few suits. It underlay that fandom would support JYJ much more.
And even the many medias evaluated that the worth of TVXQ would be multimillion-dollar including all financial things.
to that extent, everyone knew the worth and the power of TVXQ's name.
At those times, TVXQ's popularity reached its peak in Japan.
By the way, only JYJ didn't realize it, their claims that just because of doing a cosmetic business, JYJ gave up the TVXQ and then came out have how much persuasive power is.
JYJ also spoke their stuffiness about those things through their official interview.
And the fandom to use the name of TVXQ criticized SM, on the other hand, we didn't choose the separation or independence it's because we considered that HM's position to stand the same with SM.
Actually the circumstances to disband TVXQ became a fixed fact so fandom didn't act to adjust a difference of opinion between members on purpose. But ultimately fans knew the worth of TVXQ's name much more. If every member acts separately, it'll seem more powerful that TVXQ's huge fandom will support them.
For example.. although the TVXQ's fandom already split up internally, but formally we could tell to live together purposeful.
And better or not, because we knew that every 5 member have the equal right to enjoy 'the worth' of TVXQ's name, we think fans didn't intentionally break up themselves.
Though we never tell that the possibility of reunion won't happen, now they are broken up, because many fans thought that TVXQ's fandom would be helpful to each 5 members, fans haven't break their fandom.
But the fandom can't maintain the formation to help to all of members because HM announced to use the name of TVXQ. We truly lost the minimum purpose to sustain.
Other three members told they are still TVXQ's members but they work using the name of JYJ like a project group because TVXQ commonly call to be made up with 5 members.
We want to ask HM. Don't you think that the talking like JYJ would be the response to fans to maintain TVXQ's fandom as the last consideration?
And the more disappointing thing is that people think HM criticize JYJ through the main song of their album.
Fans are enthusiasts like crazy people but they can't like that some members of the band criticize the others without question. They have the thoughts.
But their appearance to show to the public and their fans will be remembered impressively and then it'll be more possible to be on everyone's lips.
**'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ' is very famous fancafe in Korea. This fancafe existed since tvxq debut, never waver once. In the past, 5 members left the mentions for fans. So many Cassiopeia wanted to join TCT.**
**And DBDN, Poplez, UERUBI, DC, etc.. Many fansites are reaching similar decisions as I've told before..**
**I don't want to tell this. So I didn't answer the questions about the situation in Korea for several days. But I think international fans have to know the situation in Korea and they have the right to know. There is a proverb in Korea. "Palms never hide the sky."**
**Some of you will attack me again. But it is the reality. Some of you also think Korean fans are arrogant. But if many Korean fans boycott TVXQ as duo, they never work in even overseas. Because they don't make profits, SM will never support them. If so, some of you will think they'll work in overseas. But it'll be impossible. SM is not charity. SM is the company to seek making profits. For instance, CSJH... they were popular in overseas but they weren't in Korea. Have you ever heard about CSJH's new album?**
**I don't want to impose to stand one side. But The way things look, the possiblity of reunion is remote. To cover the truth is not the best way. Sometimes we need a cool-headed assessment of the situation. I want to tell you this.**
This is the official position of 'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ' about TVXQ as a duo.
Hello. This is the sysop of 'the Twenties Cassiopeias for TVXQ'(TCT). After passing the 2010 that was harder we expected but felt fresh, it was to come the New Year. I wish all of you a Happy New Year.
And as a sysop, I'm very sorry to announce the notice like today, to many our members with TCT for 7 years.
If it's possible to be with all of you, it may be better. Because TCT that held barely under the big justification of '5 each member are the TVXQ' lost even the justification, I became to announce the official notice.
In fact, through last official notice, we appeared the position of our managers and you'll already predict the major opinion. So it's not surprised and not brandnew, predeterminate thing.
In the early of December.
Jung Yunho & Shim Changmin announced to start to work as TVXQ. So TCT lost the identity of the fancafe of TVXQ to consists of 5 members. Because from now TVXQ became to call just Yunho & Changmin officially.
Of course, because SM & HM monopolize the name of TVXQ, Homin are not enough to get the authenticity of 'the real TVXQ' from the public and other 3 members.
Because the authenticity of TVXQ naturally establish to fulfill the requirements, TVXQ is a boy band to be made up with Yunho, Jaejoong, Yuchun, Junsu, Changmin and they are ultimately acceptable appearance to the public including other members and fans.
Yunho & Changmin don't secure the TVXQ's authenticity as they just announced to use the name of TVXQ one-sidedly without an agreement of other members to have the equal right and to be against the fans' opinion.
But now they announced 'the real TVXQ is just two of us' to use the word of 'the authenticity'. And SM also can't deny to rule out other members from the group of TVXQ.
There was a group to have a similar process to break up but we've never seen to announce to use the group's name just like this. Because they knew what the minimum consideration is to other members and their fans.
HM could work not to use the name as much as you like as JYJ.
And they clearly knew to exist other members' fans in TVXQ's fandom. If so, at least, they had to ask to be excused as a matter of courtesy and that is the proprieties to fans who have support for 7 years.
But they didn't express the words of sorriness
and insisted on aery justification like authenticity.. We cannot help thinking to ignore us without a consideration. Because of this, there are so many fans to feel disappointment and despondency.
And that is a natural result.
Besides, if they remembered the rumors that SM made the rotation of TVXQ's member, they feel disappointment more about the announcement.
Some of you remember the contents of documents to agree between SM and members. In the document, there was a desperation to keep their members although they had an unfair contract for 13years.
Some of Homin fans distorted just the part of '13 years' in the document. So we are struck dumb with amazement.
However, at those times, absolutely all members, and their parents who asked to help to keep the TVXQ, and the fans who worked to keep members without sleeping at united fansite remembered the core of the documents.
'TVXQ means to be made up with Jung Yunho, Kim Jaejoong, Park Yuchun, Kim Junsu, Shim Changmin. And the worth and the influence that TVXQ has are created by 5 members. So if one of them is ruled out or added, that wouldn't be TVXQ.'
And emphasizing to leave the document to have legal force by concert between SM & members, their parents including Yunho's father to ask to post the contents as above knew more especially.
And many fans & other members made to feel some kinds of despondency to announce that they use the name of TVXQ. If fans use the word like sense of betrayal, it is right like this case.
Of course, when we faced to meet a situation hard to tell that JYJ came out from SM and HM left, SM and HM overused the word of 'betrayal' with asserting that JYJ came out because of 'cosmetic'
But all of TVXQ's fandom expressed to give the support the opinion of JYJ and we've criticized to use [SM unfair contract] as the front of sentence and now we've continued to criticize about SM. It means the claim of SM and HM wouldn't accept to the fandom.
Why does it happen? Is it because there're much more JYJ fans in this fandom?
If there is person to answer 'yes', he or she is never disqualified to say 'the truth' of 'the justice'.
If they have the belief about their claim, in this fandom, they confidently protested that SM didn't give members as an unfair treatment and they had to suggest the basis whoever could be acceptable.
But some of HM fans stole ex-DNBN's domain and then posted something to blame JYJ to come out from SM. We could find the prerequisite 'SM also had a mistake'. It was because some of HM fans also couldn't claim like 'SM is fair and reliable group.'
When they worked together, almost of fans didn't trust SM
and because of this, the rumor of rotation could have risen massively.
Especially, the fandom of Yunho to take the initiative others at those times never forget that you were the person to protest about distrust and injustice against SM strongly.
With some of HM's fansite as the central figure, they clouded the essence of an unfair contract and empower to SM as they posted something to distort about JYJ and to make a personal attack on JYJ is not different to betray for themselves.
And now the court accepted JYJ's petition because there's a legal problem. So from the court, JYJ received the ruling like this.
'when the trial is in the march, SM never interrupts their independent work'
And FTC ordered the 'Warning' about unfair contracts against SM. And then SM rectifies their mistake after it accepted.
These facts are real examples that their opinions like 'we never had unfair contracts' was not dishonorable in front of 'the sternness of the truth' as they always told.
Through the official interview, JYJ defined that they considered to come out from SM And before a year from the trial was raised by media. And it was not only because of an unfair contract and they felt humane disappointments from SM. It affected to come out very much.
And many fans already knew these circumstances before the trial was raised. Because of that, many fans not to understand Homin to remain SM spoke in a fierce tone their mind to feel sense of betrayal.
But some of Homin fans unconvincingly protest that JYJ accused Homin of being betrayers. We knew 'the mention to distort the 625 meeting' is the only basis. And we heard that it'll post the real fact to arrange about it.
But definite things are that many fans used the word, 'betrayal', is because they basically distrust SM. And before a year from the trial was raised by media, many fans felt betrayed from Homin because they already knew that they wanted to come out from SM.
There are multiple reasons to affect to them. Many fans' opinion didn't make suddenly just by JYJ's conspiracy as their(Homin fans' opinion) opinion.
On the contrary, everyone knew that HM practically criticized JYJ through the official documents and announcement to express their positions. Furthermore, people close to HM also have criticized JYJ persistingly. It is simply that they seriously diminished the images of JYJ as entertainers.
On the other other Hand, they told that they left place for that JYJ will turn back to SM. No one could believe the veracity of their opinion.
If they really want to reunion, how they have criticized JYJ persistingly for more one and half years.
And SM had the history that SM made the troubles with entertainers to belong to them and then they had experiences to lose a few suits. It underlay that fandom would support JYJ much more.
And even the many medias evaluated that the worth of TVXQ would be multimillion-dollar including all financial things.
to that extent, everyone knew the worth and the power of TVXQ's name.
At those times, TVXQ's popularity reached its peak in Japan.
By the way, only JYJ didn't realize it, their claims that just because of doing a cosmetic business, JYJ gave up the TVXQ and then came out have how much persuasive power is.
JYJ also spoke their stuffiness about those things through their official interview.
And the fandom to use the name of TVXQ criticized SM, on the other hand, we didn't choose the separation or independence it's because we considered that HM's position to stand the same with SM.
Actually the circumstances to disband TVXQ became a fixed fact so fandom didn't act to adjust a difference of opinion between members on purpose. But ultimately fans knew the worth of TVXQ's name much more. If every member acts separately, it'll seem more powerful that TVXQ's huge fandom will support them.
For example.. although the TVXQ's fandom already split up internally, but formally we could tell to live together purposeful.
And better or not, because we knew that every 5 member have the equal right to enjoy 'the worth' of TVXQ's name, we think fans didn't intentionally break up themselves.
Though we never tell that the possibility of reunion won't happen, now they are broken up, because many fans thought that TVXQ's fandom would be helpful to each 5 members, fans haven't break their fandom.
But the fandom can't maintain the formation to help to all of members because HM announced to use the name of TVXQ. We truly lost the minimum purpose to sustain.
Other three members told they are still TVXQ's members but they work using the name of JYJ like a project group because TVXQ commonly call to be made up with 5 members.
We want to ask HM. Don't you think that the talking like JYJ would be the response to fans to maintain TVXQ's fandom as the last consideration?
And the more disappointing thing is that people think HM criticize JYJ through the main song of their album.
Fans are enthusiasts like crazy people but they can't like that some members of the band criticize the others without question. They have the thoughts.
But their appearance to show to the public and their fans will be remembered impressively and then it'll be more possible to be on everyone's lips.