Comments | xf_rewatch: 9x05 4-D

southoffebruary in xf_rewatch

9x05 4-D

Oct 21, 2008 07:58

( Read more... )

episode post: season 9

Comments 18

madshrubbery October 20 2008, 22:17:22 UTC

Ahh, watching them die was so pleasant. That is all.

luciddreamer326 October 20 2008, 22:53:15 UTC

I have to admit to liking this episode. *ducks head*

southoffebruary October 21 2008, 03:38:32 UTC

Hee! I dont mind it myself, like may be too strong a word for me.

What do you like about it?

luciddreamer326 October 21 2008, 20:28:58 UTC

Well, let's see. I think the overall concept is really nice. Something about Lukesh always creeped me out as well.

Not that I go around shouting this out in x files fandoms either (because I don't want to get assaulted) but I am a closet dripper. I use that term loosely too. Gah, just anything to get Doggett away from Scully. She's Mulder's. At any rate, I thought maybe they would develop this DRR from this point and had hope after this episode.

Mark Snow also does a really nice job with the music in the episode, more notably when Reyes is talking to Doggett and he asks her if she believes her theories and she just nods. GREAT MUSIC right then.

*sits* Okay, I am done.

southoffebruary October 21 2008, 23:37:30 UTC

I am a closet dripper.
Haha! Your secret is out now!! I like your point of getting Doggett away from Scully, thats one minor thing I liked, but I always felt like the relationship was very forced. *shrugs*

Thread 5

oh_galore October 20 2008, 23:21:10 UTC

this is one of my favorite episodes of the whole show. I love the idea of parallel universes and I like the chemistry between Doggett and Reyes in this episode. (*hides*)

mangomandie October 22 2008, 01:53:36 UTC

It's definitely my fav of season 9 and most of S8! *hides with you*

~Mango

leucocrystal October 21 2008, 00:10:44 UTC

One of the few great episodes of the final two seasons -- even though I still wish it could've been a Mulder/Scully thing (because that would've made it 10x more awesome), Robert and Annabeth do a very good job with it. It's a very creepy, well-executed episode. One of the last, unfortunately.

southoffebruary October 21 2008, 03:39:46 UTC

A Mulder/Scully thing for this episode would have been SO fantastic I cant even begin to imagine how great it would've been.

_folieadeux October 21 2008, 17:10:42 UTC

I wish I could contribute more, but my computer isn't working well at the moment so I can't rewatch this one.

I WILL say though that I did like this when I first saw it, from what I can recall.

southoffebruary October 21 2008, 23:38:09 UTC

Oh sure, excuses :oP

Did you like it because D&R got killed? Or just in general? LOL.

_folieadeux October 22 2008, 20:50:40 UTC

LOL in general. Back in the day I was a tiny bit gleeful over that part but I think it was a decent ep overall!