challenge 1; round 1: results

[redhour]

Thank you to those who entered this round. Unfortunately someone has to go though. With that being said, here are the results!


ELIMINATED \\ hermionesparkle


with -2 votes
Sorry to see you go, hope you stick around for voting!

VOTER'S CHOICE


with +3 votes

MOD'S CHOICE
none

TALLY:
If your number is not listed, you received no comments.
01: - - - + + = -1
03: - - = -2 | ELIMINATED
04: + + + = +3 | VOTER'S CHOICE

COMMENTS:
01.
- the icon is adorable but the stretched out text doesn't blend in well.
- I really like your crop, but I think the texture used as a background is not really fitting. Maybe a plain color would have worked better?
- Selena isn't the focus of the icon and the triangular text doesn't really work neigher
+ The crop is well done; the text fits and the shape of it adds a unique touch to it.
+ text has nice effect, plus cropping is original.

03.
- The background color seems too overwhelming compared to Sarah. Overall it also seems to be a bit plain; the text placement could have been a little more creative, centered is nice but just not here.
- cropping is "common", and text looks plain.

04.
+ lovely coloring and good font choice.
+ Flawless. Really good use of text!
+ great soft colouring and I really like that the text in centric and that 'fox' is in the same colour as the jacket

If you have a complaint/question about the results, please let me know. I will do all that I can to assist you.