challenge 1; round 2: results

[redhour]

Thank you to those who entered this round. Unfortunately someone has to go though. With that being said, here are the results!


ELIMINATED \\ melas_2ndsoul


with -3 votes
Sorry to see you go, hope you stick around for voting!

VOTER'S CHOICE


with +2 votes

MOD'S CHOICE
none

TALLY:
If your number is not listed, you received no comments.
01: + = +1
02: - - - = -3 | ELIMINATED
03: - + + + = +2 | VOTER'S CHOICE

COMMENTS:
01.
+ Nice crop.

02.
- The background doesn't fit well with the image.
- a diferent texture could have been used, as this one does not mesh well with the photo.
- The texture use is not the best one. It definitely looks like pasting the picture into the texture, that's not a good effect, in my opinion. If would have turned out prettier if you placed it at the bottom of the icon.

03.
- The coloring is a bit dark, could use some lightning and contrast.
+ Cropping and color is well done.
+ the cropping is interesting, and it has a nice beautiful coloring.
+ I like the cropping and the whole concept, winter/snow. I must say the coloring is not the best one but the overall icon is good.

If you have a complaint/question about the results, please let me know. I will do all that I can to assist you.