(Untitled)

[zevabe]

Today in Gemara shiur, I was mentally far away. While the Rav discussed a debate between Tosafot & the Nimukei Yosef, I considered it's implication for the following cases

Comments

[dhole]

In standard D&D mechanics, arrows are effectively instantanious. But you could substitute something like a Delayed Blast Fireball.

[adrianna_r]

Well, I think that the person who began the killing action (delayed as it may have been) should be named 'accessory to murder', and be dealt with as one is for attempted murder.

However, only the person who actually, directly and without delays, led to a person's death can be named the full killer.

I think this also exists in law... 'cause the guy who tried to murder, but had a time delay, could've changed his mind and saved the to-be-killed person at the last minute... so it doesn't count as a full murder...

Of course, that's just what I think... and when I refer to a proverbial 'he' I mean a person of either sex :P

[stone_]

No XP (or alignment issues) are given for killing somebody that is already considered to be dead. (Well I guess if you're a paladin or a cleric whose diety is against desecration of the dead there may be issues...)