round 1, challenge 1: A voting

[herphotolife]

okay everyone. submission for challenge 1: A is now shut.. unfortunately these people did not submit an icon:

cherrygeek86
setentpet
lumiscious
lilacluv

therefore, a skip was used and you can stay in the round and participate next time. you can see how many skips you have left here.

Comments

[setentpet]

Crap, I thought the deadline was friday.

FYI: comments aren't screened.

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 7 ~ The icon is over contrasted and over saturated making her face way too bright.
---2: 20 ~ The coloring is too green/yellow on her face making it unflattering and a 'unnatural' looking.

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 6 ~ Nice crop and soft coloring.
---2: 19 ~ Lovely coloring.

[yaysarah]

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 007 - the color is too light.
---2: 020 - i think the color is too green.

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 002 - i think it's really creative.
---2: 006 - it's nicely cropped.

[alwaysparis]

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
--- 005 - The coloring of the picture is a bit bland against the strong backgroung, it doesn't stand out against the text texture
--- 020 - The coloring is too yellow, giving her skin an unnatural feel

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
--- 008 - Lovely coloring
--- 002 - Beautiful composition

[gribouille]

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 007 - the character is too bright and the colour does not suit her best. You might need more contrast on this icon.
---2: 005 - the idea was nice except that another shape might have been better - a square for instance, even if it seems less original - as this cropping is not very flattering.

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 006 - the crop is very nice and the colours are simply gorgeous.
---2: 022 - very good idea, and the result looks great.

[calin_durus]

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 005 -> the focus of the icon blends too much with the burn that it distracts the eye.
---2: 020 -> the yellow makes me think Keira has Jaundice :/

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 006 --> Very nice coloring a cropping
---2: 016 --> the coloring and texture give it an antique feel, which goes really well with the feel of the image.