round 1, challenge 1: A voting

[herphotolife]

okay everyone. submission for challenge 1: A is now shut.. unfortunately these people did not submit an icon:

cherrygeek86
setentpet
lumiscious
lilacluv

therefore, a skip was used and you can stay in the round and participate next time. you can see how many skips you have left here.

Comments

[kawaiisprinkles]

I have never given critiques before. Hopefully they're ok!

2 LEAST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 005
I think that the girl's face doesn't quite stand out enough in comparison to the high contrast black and white background.
---2: 007
Although the image and the bar of text are lovely separately, there doesn't seem to be much harmony between the two when put together.

2 BEST QUALITY ICONS
---1: 001
I enjoy the composition of the icon greatly. It confuses my eyes but I like it.
---2: 018
I love how the icon is almost split into two sections by the flowers. The colours also give a wonderful spring feel.

[herphotolife]

CLOSED