hi everyone. this is a day late, i'm sorry. if you're a member of my other communities you will already know this is because of problems getting onto LJ. unfortunately there were a lot of people who did not submit icons:
weatheredlaw // 2 skips
cherrygeek86 // 1 skips
gribouille // 2 skips
gt22 // 4 skips
lumiscious // 1 skips
lilacluv // 1 skips
lefthandpenguin // 2 skips
gurllie1994 // 2 skips
alwaysparis - 4 skips
father_a_w_a_y4 3 skips
(
Read more... )
Comments 13
First choice: 001 - the pictures' aspect ratio looks a bit distorted, and the icon is a little too busy
Second choice: 011 - the icon looks blurry and a bit washed out
best quality:
008 - great use of negative space
Reply
Also, the rules say to vote for 3 lesser quality and 2 best quality. However, the form only mentions 2 lesser quality and 1 best quality. Which one should we vote for?
I followed the form, but can edit my vote if necessary.
Reply
first choice: 1
There is a lot going on in this icon. The combination of images in this icon make it look cramped. The picture on the left looks stretched.
second choice: 2
The person in the foreground of the icon is sharp to the point that the image quality appears lessened. The background is very busy and distracting.
third choice: 14
The quality of the image does not appear as smooth as the others. The colors are rather dull and don't grab one's attention.
best quality:
first choice: 9
Great use of the image! The yellow background works really well and helps the characters stand out.
second choice: 4
The shadows are a bit too dark in this one, but otherwise the icon is well-made. The text is a nice touch in this one.
-----
Um, I went with the numbers mentioned in the instructions, so I hope that was right.
Also, I don't know if the affiliate plugs were meant to be in the voting form, but that and the lj-cut closing tag are in there ^^;;
Reply
FIRST CHOICE LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY: number 11 is out of focus and the colours are dull
second choice LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY: number 14 can't make out any detail so it doesn't catch the eye
best quality:
one BEST QUALITY CHOICE & REASONS WHY: number 8. all the empty space makes the characters stand out
please also check out disneytheme, natureicontest and my new lj community which really needs entries for the first challenge meangirlsstills
Reply
FIRST CHOICE LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY:1 The icon and text looks very low quality and flat.
second choice LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY: 5 The texture is very distracting and draws your eye to the upper blank/ dark half. The image is also very blurred.
third choice LEAST QUALITY & REASONS WHY
best quality:9 Everything is so bright it washes out the people and is very distracting.
one BEST QUALITY CHOICE & REASONS WHY: 7 It is very simple and eye pleasing
Reply
Leave a comment