Ok, overall, I liked your application. I really apologize for harping on a couple of things, but it doesn't mean that I don't think you're right for the community. The only reason I'm squibing you at this time is because you responded to votes on your application. But since you said you'd be back in a month, I figured I'd give you my thoughts anyway, just to keep in mind
( ... )
I didn't get much of a vibe other than Slytherin and I don't think I can really sort you fairly by just guessing at another house. I'm sure if you get squibbed, you'll be back in a month, so I hope to see you then. For now, squib.
SlytherClaw leik woah. :DDDDDtanakiJanuary 9 2006, 05:47:56 UTC
First off, I agree with Brazenbitch. Your Slytherin felt pastede on yey. You seem to want to seem Slytherin and I felt as if you wrote your app to come off as your interpretation of OMG HARDCORE SLYTH. It may be how you really are, but you must understand that people are hyper-sensitive to Slytherin pushes and to push Slytherin or even be Slytherin you need to be extra subtle. You weren't. Which honestly puts me more in the mind of a Gryff than Slyth. And some things were just off for Slyth, anyway.
I felt as if some of the canon answers were really off. :/
And I have a bone to pick with your Voldemort analysis.
[Voldemort] began making a plethora of elementary, idiotic mistakes that led to his eventual downfall in Godric's Hollow.
I disagree. He made no mistakes. And if he did they weren't elementary or idiotic. How was he to know that LURV would disable him? Normal thought processes don't include fear of being struck dead by the fuzzies and fluff bunnies.
I find it difficult to believe that the Auror's College could neither
( ... )
Throughout your application, I was also getting a slight feeling that there was a forced Slytherin about you, but I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and refrain from squibbing you.
While I did have a bit of a time picking another House to go with your Slytherin, I think I've decided on Slytherclaw.
You're self-aware and intelligent, and throughout your application, in many, many answers, I found an analytical 'claw side coming out. I'm having a hard time explaining it at the moment [but I am rather sick, so, hey, cut me some slack. XD], but it's just... there. I can't put it into eloquent, elucidated terms, but you've definitely got a Ravenclaw side to you.
So, again, I think Slytherclaw's your best match. And good luck with your sorting. Your application was well thought-out and showed a lot of effort, so I hope to see you around here soon.
I'm going to say Slytherclaw - you're obviously Slyth (I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that the Slyth was genuine and not pushed) and I think Claw is the next although faint house for you.
Comments 32
Reply
Reply
I felt as if some of the canon answers were really off. :/
And I have a bone to pick with your Voldemort analysis.
[Voldemort] began making a plethora of elementary, idiotic mistakes that led to his eventual downfall in Godric's Hollow.
I disagree. He made no mistakes. And if he did they weren't elementary or idiotic. How was he to know that LURV would disable him? Normal thought processes don't include fear of being struck dead by the fuzzies and fluff bunnies.
I find it difficult to believe that the Auror's College could neither ( ... )
Reply
Reply
While I did have a bit of a time picking another House to go with your Slytherin, I think I've decided on Slytherclaw.
You're self-aware and intelligent, and throughout your application, in many, many answers, I found an analytical 'claw side coming out. I'm having a hard time explaining it at the moment [but I am rather sick, so, hey, cut me some slack. XD], but it's just... there. I can't put it into eloquent, elucidated terms, but you've definitely got a Ravenclaw side to you.
So, again, I think Slytherclaw's your best match. And good luck with your sorting. Your application was well thought-out and showed a lot of effort, so I hope to see you around here soon.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment