9.1 Voting

[sidhex3]

Unfortunately, rebelstrike21 and infanta_teribla did not submit their entries by the deadline and are disqualified.

Peer's Choice winner will be the comm's new default icon.

Rules:
- You will be voting for ONE lesser quality icons and for ONE best icon. Vote according to quality and technique, not personal preference. If there is a problem with your vote, I will ask you to

Comments

[cyanidexbeauty]

LEAST:
#05 - The neck added in doesn't seem to make any sense with the picture given.

BEST:
#03 - The coloring of the icon pops and just flows really well with the original photo.

[holidaylights]

LEAST:
#09 - The color and font of the text and the texture at the bottom don't match with anything else in the image.

BEST:
#02 - Absolutely gorgeous coloring.

[gerryswenchie]

LEAST:
#010 - colouring maes the icon look washed out and a little blurry

BEST:
#009 - crop and colouring is great,nice use of text too

[setentpet]

LEAST:
#10 - The coloring is a bit downplayed, would have been nice with some brighter coloring and the light textures distract a little from the cactus.

BEST:
#04 - Nicely cropped and colored.

I may not be in this round, but I'm still voting, dammit!

[ender839]

LEAST:
#007 - The image looks pixellated, which is more than likely a result of oversharpening, especially around the rose area. The contrast between the uber-sharp flower and the really blurry greenery is also very jarring and detracts from the icon's impact.

BEST:
#002 - The color scheme is pleasantly unexpected for a challenge about flowers - the dynamic contrast is also very well done.

Re: I may not be in this round, but I'm still voting, dammit!

[sidhex3]

lol...you'll be allowed to submit for the comeback challenge, if you're interested. ;)