Примечание к Забаниваниям

May 06, 2010 01:12

Я забанил bbb и, поскольку это вызвало некоторое брожение умов, хочу пояснить.

Часть Первая. О Некоторой Глупости )

пациент

Leave a comment

multi_persona May 7 2010, 00:56:03 UTC
"Ты вот уже несколько раз пытался перевести разговор на gay baiting, и обвинить меня в гомофобии."

вы неправильно используете этот термин. кажется вы имеете в виду gay bashing - совсем не gay baiting. последнее - это когда мужчина стрэйт намеренно притворяется гэем чтобы "поймать" и потом унизить, или просто заставить выйти из клозета гэя..

Reply

arbat May 7 2010, 02:02:40 UTC
Я, пожалуй, неправильно употребил термин. Вы, кстати, тоже совершенно неправильно его понимаете.

Я имел в виду, - он решил, что хороший способ победить меня в споре, - это обвинить меня в гомофобии.

Reply

multi_persona May 7 2010, 17:10:22 UTC
i see. neither gay-baiting nor gay-bashing would be correct here.

there is no such single word (yet!) to describe "хороший способ победить меня в споре, - это обвинить меня в гомофобии".

it would be nice to have a term for that, since this is a common PC thing - to accuse (directly or subtly) someone of mysogynism, racism, homophobia, when the conversation is about something entirely different. at least, he "accused" you very subtly.

BTW i can't help but find it ironic that you banned user bbb for being uppity and condescending. you (or your LJ persona) is never uppity but condescending you are, quite a bit. i know you like proofs and direct quotes, and not empty accusations - i have no time or desire to go reading through old posts looking for examples, but i promise to point one out to you if i see it in the future posts or conversations.

of course you can argue that coming from the a host of a blog, superior attitude is one thing, and from a guest, a completely different one.

Reply

arbat May 7 2010, 22:52:17 UTC
Personally, I am less concerned about terminology.

I don't like when personal attacks are substituted for an argument. I like it even less when those attacks are pure libel. And, if it is directed at me personally, - well, that I choose not to accept.

As for condescending, then sure thing, I can be condescending as hell. And, on occasion, I can even call someone an idiot or a fascist. I am also known to tell some people to go and fuck themselves. In other words, yes, sometimes I offend people.

If I do not want to offend someone, I try to remedy the situation.

And, conversely, if I do not try to fix things, it means that in the best case, I do not give a shit if I offended that person. In the worst, I wanted to.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up