(Untitled)

Oct 26, 2004 15:12

I've been meaning to post my socratic adventure from last friday, but I haven't gotten around to it until now ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 10

hobbesianegoist October 26 2004, 21:00:38 UTC
Well done my friend, well done.
I salute you.
I wonder what he would have to say about freedom if you had gotten to the topic of "free speech zones"

Reply


raistlinjones October 26 2004, 23:40:39 UTC
What's too bad is that there are arguments he could have made - he just hadn't thought anything through. For example, he could have said "Terrorists kill people. All freedom is dependent on being alive. Thus, terrorists significantly reduce freedom, and stopping them therefore prevents this reduction."

This obviously assumes that the Patriot Act deters terrorists to such an extent as to overwhelm the freedoms lost, but a Bush supporter would probably assert that this is the case.

Hopefully you won't have to drink the Hemlock anytime soon.

Reply

artificialchaos October 27 2004, 05:42:19 UTC
I'm not sure. You run around saying thinks like "All freedom is dependent on being alive." and you're sure to get my inquiring all over again.

Reply

raistlinjones October 27 2004, 10:46:27 UTC
This obviously assumes that an afterlife is false.

Reply

artificialchaos October 27 2004, 16:11:21 UTC
Not even. Is it not freedom if someone dies to protect it?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up