Second Star to the Right (Part II) ~ SGA (McShep)

[atlantis_chat]

Title: Second Star to the Right
Author: icantfollow
Characters: Rodney McKay/John Sheppard
Prompt: #046 Star
Word Count: ~11,000
Genre: AU
Rating: PG13
Summary: Rodney's pretty sure that if his time with John hasn't scarred him for life, then at the very least he's going to grow up with a fish fetish.

Part I

Comments

[lorraine_gayley]

This-was lovely. I've actually been *waiting* for someone to write a McShep Peter Pan AU for a few months now. Thank you so much for doing it so well! I liked all the elements here that you incorporated; the Wraith and their connection with growing up was especially nice. Thanks again!

[tradesland]

This is absolutely lovely :):):)

Thank you so much :)

[fathomlessspite]

This is definitely my favourite piece of fanfic i've ever read, not even jus mcshep or atlantis.

Peter Pan was just my childhood, and is still my favourite kids story because it doesnt have the traditional happily ever after.

I loved the way you melded atlantis with it, it made me laugh and cry and I'm going to read it again tommorrow morning. I'd read it again right now if i wasnt going to go to sleep, lol

Thank you!

[ivoryraven22000]

Wow. Just.. wow. This whole story was written with the awful sort of bittersweetness that had me on the edge of tears half the time. And the ending! Perfect. Not too sad, not too saccharine, just the right amount of hope. As well, I've got to say you portrayed Rodney's confusion, his hate-him-because-he-loves-him attitude toward John, and his eventual sad recognition of his 'adult-ness', all without any long mental soliloquies. So, I just mean to say, thank you for writing this.

[klo_the_hobbit]

ASlmlkmalksda and now I have to go to work, all pent up and saddened and happy. Sad and hopeful and lovely. Thank you!