So, what's it all add up to? It's hard to say. But me, I'd say this was a test...for Sam and Dean.

[cherie_morte]

So, all the excitement leading up to the 200th Supernatural episode got to me, I'll admit. I honestly don't want to talk about the episode, or rather I don't think anyone wants to hear what I have to say. I'm really glad most everyone seemed to enjoy it, though

Comments

[mangacat201]

I cannot believe the amount of geekery that goes into purposefully rating 200 episodes of television (oh wait I totally can), but while I don't agree with all of your choices I can definitely totally get on board with the top ten, BECAUSE AWESOME. I'm sorry if this latest ep didn't hit a high note for you, but that's ok, because if we all liked Show the way it goes all the time, where would the glorious fanfiction be?
I'm actually really excited for next week because that one looks... weird. Completely and utterly enjoyable weird. So.

[cherie_morte]

LOL, it took so much longer than I was expected. But, lbr, it's not like knowing how long it was gonna take would have stopped me.

Next week looks cute. I mean, I'm worn down and over ever getting excited by anything the current writers produce, but it looked cute, so maybe it will be. Stranger things have happened.

[mangacat201]

Well, it's 200 episodes! A friend and me once spent an afternoon goofing around trying to name all episodes by title (which was in the ... I think season 4 days?) and we ended missing just a couple or putting them in the wrong place, but just coming up with all the titles and then trying to remember what happened in that ep... Seriously, that's hard enough. I think I'd be able to tell if something wasn't canon before or had happened in a different way, when I saw it, but we have A LOT of material to keep straight after ten years. LOL. The showbible must be an Encyclopedia Britannica by now. What I really like though, is how the new season, no matter which way you look at the execution, has revived fandom and made the fanfic flow (especially from my own perspective) so I have to give props for that.

[cherie_morte]

I did that earlier with a Tumblr set where it was tiny pictures from each ep in order and I got all the titles up to Season 7 (except that I always screw up the Gordon episodes where one is Bloodlust and the other is Fresh Blood, I get them mixed up because they are so similar in subject as well as name!) and then from S7 it was a hot mess. XD

I don't read post-9x01 Wincest and I am not really interested in any other kind of fic, so I honestly have not noticed the increase in output, but I'm glad to hear it's happening!

[milly_gal]

Now this is EPIC!!! And there is no wrong here, you can't be wrong about the order in which you love something honey :D

[cherie_morte]

Well, I know it's not wrong! I just meant other wrong people are welcome to tell me I'm wrong. :P

[milly_gal]

LOL!

[ash48]

Oh great list! I wouldn't mind doing the same thing but, wow, doing that looks HARD.

(and I know you don't want to talk about the ep, but I did think the shout out to tentacle fic might have won it some brownie points with you. Or, um, maybe not...;D)

[cherie_morte]

It took practically my entire Sunday. Which is fiiinneeeee, because it's not like I have a SDMB to finish or anything. -____-

No. It didn't win any brownie points.

[killabeez]

Just seeing them all in one place is intimidating. I can only get through the top 3 before my brain goes offline.

1. In My Time of Dying
2. Mystery Spot
3. Bad Day at Black Rock
4. …nope.

[harrigan]

Those are definitely in my top 10!

[cherie_morte]

When I first started, I wrote down #1...then I wrote and rewrote #2 4 times with it being a different episode each time. And I was like, "JFC, this is going to be a loooong night."

[killabeez]

I do find it really interesting that "Swan Song" is your #1. I think I might have agreed, had it been the last episode of the series. Then again, probably not, because S4-5 was such a bitter and unhappy time for me.

I still haven't watched "Abandon All Hope." At this point, must admit that I don't think I ever will. /wimp

[cackling_madly]

How did you do this?! I can never decide on my top three let alone ranking all 200.

But the fact that 4.01 is only #24 on your list? Gurl...

[cherie_morte]

24 IS SO HIGH. IT IS SUCH A GOOD EPISODE. THERE ARE JUST SUCH FUCKING GOOD EPISODES ABOVE IT. *hands*

It literally took an entire Sunday. This is an entire day of my life.

[cackling_madly]

Lol sorry! I just love that episode, especially the first five minutes. Jensen is perfection in those first five minutes

[cherie_morte]

IT'S SUCH A GOOD EPISODE. THERE ARE SO MANY SUCH GOOD EPISODES.

*raptor screech*