Leave a comment

Comments 56

demented2468 July 7 2011, 23:22:50 UTC
One of the key things of this book is how human Dumbledore becomes. Before, in Harrys eyes, the reader has seen him as this sort of greatness that was beyond human. He knew all and did no faults. Now see him in a while new light
- Do you think that Dumbledore looks on Harry too highly?
- Views on Dumbledore’s view of those that seek to give themselves too much control?
- Would you of made the same choice Harry did ?
- Love the last line of this so much

Reply

polite_fiction July 7 2011, 23:35:32 UTC
Do you think that Dumbledore looks on Harry too highly?
Well, I think Dumbledore acknowledges that Harry has some flaws, which he does, but I do agree that Harry is extraordinarily selfless, even with individuals that he does not necessarily like.

Would you of made the same choice Harry did ?
You know? I don't know. I think I would, but it's one of those situations where you don't really know what you'd do until you're in that situation.

Reply

acmeeoy July 8 2011, 02:52:51 UTC
- Do you think that Dumbledore looks on Harry too highly?

Kind of understandable since he mentored Harry for so long.

- Views on Dumbledore’s view of those that seek to give themselves too much control?<.i>

I have similar views when being married, having children, or taking care of pets. I think I'd be terrible at all of them, so I won't be involved or have any of them. In addition, marriage doesn't interest me whatsoever.

Reply


demented2468 July 7 2011, 23:24:08 UTC
So many good quotes

Reply

busha69 July 7 2011, 23:37:32 UTC
yes:)

Reply

acmeeoy July 8 2011, 02:53:21 UTC
Dumbledore is a Fountain of Quotable Sayings.

Reply


sodoesrachael July 7 2011, 23:30:47 UTC
THIS CHAPTER. WHAT CAN I SAY ABOUT THIS CHAPTER?

Reply

acmeeoy July 8 2011, 02:59:47 UTC
Dumbledore loves to give life lessons and explain things. Death would certaintly not stop him from doing that.

Reply


polite_fiction July 7 2011, 23:30:57 UTC
“Tell me one last thing,” said Harry. “Is this real? Or has this been happening inside my head?”

Dumbledore beamed at him, and his voice sounded loud and strong in Harry’s ears even though the bright mist was descending again, obscuring his figure.

“Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?”


... )

Reply

busha69 July 7 2011, 23:38:12 UTC
one of my most fave things ever said in HP

Reply

wakeupinacity July 8 2011, 00:00:35 UTC
same!

Reply

acmeeoy July 8 2011, 03:01:15 UTC
I just combined science with magic in concerns with afterlife talking. I just blew your mind. And exploded your tear ducts.

Reply


sodoesrachael July 7 2011, 23:31:39 UTC
I mentioned in the last post how ANGREH I was at Dumbledore when Harry realizes he's been raised to die at the right moment. Like, I hated him.

But in this chapter, I forgave him. :)

Reply

busha69 July 7 2011, 23:49:58 UTC
i actually started to LOVE Dumbles after THE chapter XD (i was shocked,yes...but that´s it)
he is such an interesting character with this wonderful dark side

Reply

acmeeoy July 8 2011, 03:02:07 UTC
Dumbledore, like many of the other characters, expresses moments where one wants to slap them across the head.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up