I criiiiied at the Snape part and the battle scenes surrounding that. I hate Snape in the books and barely find The Prince's Tale even vaguely redeeming, but I loooooved this part of the movie. Rickman's Snape is not nearly as nasty as Rowling's, so it is far easier to sympathize and not see him as such an evil creeper.
This so much. I didn't exactly sob, but I was way more sympathetic to this version of Snape than the one in the novel. Though of course I prefer The Prince's Tale in the book.
And I LOVED LOVED LOVED the movie, just to get that out of the way.
- Voldie hugging Draco. My theatre laughed so hard. - Most of the King's Cross scene. Just felt a bit off. - Ron not hugging Harry good-bye, what?! - Neville waking up as Harry and Voldie are duking it out and tuning in the battle around him. I don't know, just the way it was blocked and put together was weird. - Harry breaking the Elder Wand before he'd repaired his own, although admittedly I didn't notice this until people pointed it out. - Hermione being the one with the dragon idea. LOL no. - Random snow all over Hogsmeade in the beginning of May. I know it's in the Scottish Highlands, but seriously? When Harry said it looked like a Christmas card, that's because it was December.
Re: WTF Momentsomgawz_jaimeeJuly 15 2011, 07:38:52 UTC
as for the snow, i think it was because of the dementors? don't they change the weather?
-snape sobbing over lily's dead body was a wtf moment for me -harry telling hermione and ron to kill the snake. subsequently, ron and hermione throwing rocks at nagini. -acting like a basilisk fang was the only way to kill a horcrux
Overall happy with the film. Yes, they changed things but most of the things still held together. Harry snapping Elder Wand without Phoenix Wand was a WTF and if that was young Snape talking at one point in flashbacks he sounded really girly.
Was worried they weren't going to have Neville kill nagini Loved the Neville taunting the death eaters part Loved the mcgonngal lines Loved filch coming in the great hall and the totally clueless line Loved hermione as bellatrix Didn't like how the epilogue kids looked older than the trio when it was their first year at hogwarts This falls under the mcgonagall lines but I loved the semus blowing things up part
Comments 437
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
This so much. I didn't exactly sob, but I was way more sympathetic to this version of Snape than the one in the novel. Though of course I prefer The Prince's Tale in the book.
Agree with the weird pacing at the beginning.
Reply
- Voldie hugging Draco. My theatre laughed so hard.
- Most of the King's Cross scene. Just felt a bit off.
- Ron not hugging Harry good-bye, what?!
- Neville waking up as Harry and Voldie are duking it out and tuning in the battle around him. I don't know, just the way it was blocked and put together was weird.
- Harry breaking the Elder Wand before he'd repaired his own, although admittedly I didn't notice this until people pointed it out.
- Hermione being the one with the dragon idea. LOL no.
- Random snow all over Hogsmeade in the beginning of May. I know it's in the Scottish Highlands, but seriously? When Harry said it looked like a Christmas card, that's because it was December.
Anything else I've missed?
Reply
-snape sobbing over lily's dead body was a wtf moment for me
-harry telling hermione and ron to kill the snake. subsequently, ron and hermione throwing rocks at nagini.
-acting like a basilisk fang was the only way to kill a horcrux
Reply
-voldy and bellatrix crumbling and disappearing
Reply
Reply
Reply
Was worried they weren't going to have Neville kill nagini
Loved the Neville taunting the death eaters part
Loved the mcgonngal lines
Loved filch coming in the great hall and the totally clueless line
Loved hermione as bellatrix
Didn't like how the epilogue kids looked older than the trio when it was their first year at hogwarts
This falls under the mcgonagall lines but I loved the semus blowing things up part
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment