Comments | kuraku: (без темы)

kuraku

(Untitled)

Nov 30, 2008 16:05

i'm getting a little annoyed by everyone dissing twilight ( Read more... )

Comments 12

cynbaby December 1 2008, 00:25:15 UTC

I poke fun at everything...even things I like. ♥

cynbaby December 1 2008, 04:11:59 UTC

oh, that definitely wasn't directed at you specifically. people are so judging it based on its fantards. also, i thought that post you linked was awesome and if i was interpreting certain things her way then i would have agreed. however, i believe that you can read your own beliefs into a book and just read from the author's (unintended) perspective.

cloudsnapper December 2 2008, 20:00:53 UTC

I hope I haven't dissed Twilight without mentioning that I'm not part of the target audience, and that I haven't read it. I read much much worse fluff! (Fairy princess porn? I have no right to diss anything!)

I can't belive I'm admitting this... cultstatus_bo0m December 5 2008, 04:08:58 UTC

The first half of the movie was crap and it didn't explain ANYTHING. The second half was much better, but it was still good enough to make me want to read the books and a TON of stuff online (THAT'S RIGHT, MR. ST.JOHN!) After reading a TON of stuff online I went to see it again and all the stuff that didn't make sense had a point and it was MUCH better. They also have admitted that they made a misleading preview, by including a lot of action in it, so that it would sucker the boys in.. but that's what they get for not finding out what it's actually about.

HOORAY FOR FLUFF!

Re: I can't belive I'm admitting this... cultstatus_bo0m December 5 2008, 04:18:13 UTC

i can't WAIT to see the movie. i loved all the books a lot. i'm glad you like them too! i'm giving jessica the first two for Christmas.

Re: I can't belive I'm admitting this... rsit December 5 2008, 15:51:08 UTC

Who wrote this? Giving the first two to Jessica Jackson or Jessica Runyan? I hope not Runyan... cause Becca and I were gonna give her the first two books...

I guess we could give them to Megan instead.

Re: I can't belive I'm admitting this... kuraku December 5 2008, 18:28:50 UTC

patrick, honey, it was me.

Thread 5

skasumi December 7 2008, 18:49:01 UTC

Oh darling, this is one of the many reasons I adore you! I can't tell you how annoying it is for me to explain to people that I enjoy Twilight as fluff (and the movie wasn't half bad!) but I don't consider it good writing at all. It's more of a guilty pleasure, it doesn't have the best storyline, there are some things that just don't make sense or are plain stupid, but it's an interesting read.

kuraku December 7 2008, 20:01:14 UTC

well, i differ from you slightly in that i think it was decently written and i'm not sure what didn't make sense or is stupid. but then again, i'm a take it like it is kind of person and people usually have to explain to me what isn't right about whatever it is.

I don't know becca colliding_x December 9 2008, 00:53:38 UTC

I haven't read the books, so I'll refrain from any direct criticism of the series, but I'd like to say a few words on whether or not a thing is open to criticism based on intent ( ... )

Re: I don't know becca kuraku December 9 2008, 05:43:19 UTC

i totally agree with what you're saying david. a lot of the people i was reacting to were saying things like "sparkly vampires! lame!" instead of being intelligent about it ( ... )