First bit.
It’s easier to fall into step beside them than to fight it, really. Sam can survive this newest and most difficult lie because, underneath everything he says to any of them and every task he attempts to pick up without admitting that he doesn’t know how to be a soldier, is his unfaltering belief that sooner or later he will be able to go
(
Read more... )
Comments 61
Ahem. What I meant to say was, wow, this is really very beautifully done. I have to confess, when I read the summary I was slightly doubtful, but this really, really works. Gene's concern as a leader for his team translates perfectly here: you've highlighted some of the best aspects of his character, I think. Their relationship is wonderfully interpreted, and I adored the idea that Sam is shown to be a man out of time because there's something different in his eyes.
This is one of the most original pieces that I've read in a long time. Really good job!
Reply
Thank you so very much for the lovely, lovely comment; it really means a lot that you enjoyed it, because I was massively and entirely uncertain about the whole shebang. You ftw!
Reply
Reply
Reply
And the ending, and, and, everything was so right, and your Gene made me hurt, and ILU.
I have to go eat dinner now, but when I get back from Dad's this weekend, I will come back and leave you a better comment, because I heart you in your face and this fic made me all nnnghy.
Reply
I HEART YOU XXXX
Reply
Reply
Reply
There's just enough of the spirit of LoM and just enough of the history for this to work really well, I think. It's a great idea well executed, I only wish you'd continued with the other times.
Clever of you to wind the other elements of the show in too; the TCG, Annie, even Sam's distrust of Ray. Gene's transition from Sheriff to Captain works well, even if he does seem a somewhat softer character in this piece than he does in LoM.
This is having a lovely space in my memories, it's fantastic. :D
Reply
Interesting that you noted how much softer Gene is in this; that was a conscious decision, but I wasn't sure it worked. The thing is, that this Gene is an Officer (not only that; a Captain!), which meant he was almost certainly born into the upper or middle classes, privately educated, etc. There's a bit on the commentaries where one of the creators talks about how intelligent Gene is, how if he'd been born in the right time and place he might have been an academic, and I thought, Hmmm. But I do expect that it looked very much like poor characterisation, ahaha!
Thank you again, really, I'm so glad you liked it. ♥
Reply
Leave a comment