GD&TOP Album Review (Tracks 6-11)

Jan 02, 2011 01:24


I feel bad for leaving this unfinished for so many days.
So flattered that people actually came to read my review!  ;____;
My thoughts on the album is pretty solid now, just waiting to be put down on paper.  Go go go~


Read more... )

gd, review, top

Leave a comment

Comments 26

unf_mark January 1 2011, 17:52:11 UTC
I love the club crawl interpretation of the album, I hadn't thought of it in that way before :D ( ... )

Reply

o_srsly January 1 2011, 18:11:29 UTC
You get the first cookie! LOL.

Pass the Parcel! I loved that game as a kid. When I was writing the review, I wanted to use the analogy that Donkey used in Shrek, which is that TOP had many layers, like an onion. But I felt that maybe that would spoil the whole moodiness of the review :D If we could, I would want MVs for all the songs in this album, kind of like how Jay Chou used to do with his albums, but that was because he was so interested in directing and is such a huge narcissist. /digress

Oh Yeah is definitely on the bottom of my list, since I have very minimal feelings of thrill with this song already, but having Minzy and CL sing to Bom's parts yesterday helped a little bit, I felt it refreshed the whole song to an extent...

I have already written more than 4000 words in this review (if only I could have gotten my essays done so quickly lol), so right now I am feeling all worded out, but I loved reading your response (and so timely too!) My only hope is that I would like the Big Bang album as much as this one. :)

Reply

unf_mark January 1 2011, 19:09:20 UTC
The whole album in video format = my idea of heaven :D

Oh Yeah sounds nice but is a little too repetetive. I enjoyed Minzy singing the chorus, but it still didn't make me love the song. I don't dislike it, it just doesn't do much for me.

GD and TOP are the two BB members I'm most interested in, and I enjoyed their album so much, so I hope I won't be disappointed in the group's album when (if...) it comes out. While GD has said he wants the album to be memorable and different, it will still be more mainstream kpop than their duo album. But we'll see - I don't want to start worrying about it before we even have a proper date!!

Reply

o_srsly January 3 2011, 07:53:55 UTC
I will probably pay 10x what I paid for the album for a video format one.

Yeah, I know what you mean about being most interested in GTOP. They are my biases without a doubt, and I worry that this album has spoiled me for good (Well if there is a Vol 1, there must be a Vol 2! /fingerscrossed). But I trust that GD and (to a lesser extent) YG knows what they are doing, so yeah... I don't want to start worrying also.

/puts GTOP album back on repeat

Reply


suivezlapiste January 1 2011, 21:35:17 UTC
You're pretty awesome for doing this and deserve some of those cookies, too :)
I'm more of a lurker, don't comment much, but this review deserves a comment.
I was reading an interview with TOP, he was talking about Oh Mom - “Oh mom” is based on an actual episode. I can’t exactly detail on that but basically it’s my letter to one friend who is very, very sick. It’s a very meaningful piece for me which wasn’t planned in the track list but got included because I wanted it to be there badly.
I wish we could figure it out, I feel like if we knew what he was talking about there, we might appreciate it more.
Thanks again for doing this! :D

Reply

o_srsly January 3 2011, 07:45:34 UTC
OH I WILL NOM THOSE COOKIES.
Those are my second most wanted cookies, behind this:

... )

Reply


atavistique January 2 2011, 00:08:10 UTC
1) Well done, you. *hwugs and pats you on back* Now go and have a good sleep-off.
2) *noms cookie and feeds crumbs to Gaho, just because he's adorbz and looks like barrel bread*
3) We agree on many points about this album. You know, I did also point out to you that "Obsession" reminded me of "She's Gone", but I'm not sure you read that comment, so *shrugs*.
4) I'm sitting at the edge of my chair nibbling my fingernails that there's going to be more GTOP rock. Because GTOP rock rocks (yes, I just wanted to say that XDD).
5) I know about OH MOM being about a sick friend. But it all depends on who that "friend" is and in what sense (s)he is "sick". I have a few theories, some of which strike even me as ridiculous... but there you go, that's a topic for another entry sometime. :P
6) How much was the album?? Because if it's under 200HKD I'm thinking of getting the blue as well.

Reply

o_srsly January 3 2011, 07:48:40 UTC
1) Thanks bb, I did. Which is why I abandoned my LJ for like, 3 days.
2) BARREL BREAD YES.
3) You and I have exchanged so many thoughts on the album, that I guess you must have mentioned it too. It's just I first saw the idea on a Kvip fanpage.
4) I will be forever waiting for GD&TOP Vol 2. T-T
5) Write that entry. PLZ.
6) 150HKD. :)

Reply

atavistique January 3 2011, 12:06:43 UTC
1) You slept for 3 days?? XDD
2) Isn't it just? *cuddles dougy*
3) *shrugs nonchalantly*
4) YESH PLZ LET THERE BE GTOP2.
5) Have done. :D
6) *strokes chin* And you are certain you cannot get the BB album?

Reply

atavistique January 3 2011, 12:12:51 UTC
BTW, did you hear that apparently Gaho is now married??

Reply


minamelody January 2 2011, 22:37:54 UTC
Oh gosh, you are a brilliant reviewer :D This was really entertaining to read and I LOVE your interpretation of Obsession/Nightmare...It seems a lot clearer to me now. Thanks for sharing :)

Reply

o_srsly January 3 2011, 07:22:45 UTC
You're welcome! I'm so glad it was helpful. I sometimes think that if you don't write down how you feel about something, especially something that hits me as viscerally as this, you will lose it. ;__;

Reply


byronsbitch January 2 2011, 22:47:31 UTC
I think I need to buy you a present for the Obsession review and explanation. I've read a few translations of the song but I really felt like I was missing something. Speaking a language other than english myself I know how hard it is to translate to english sometimes. Those little intricacies are lost and sometimes the whole meaning behind a sentence can come out warped or just completely different from the intended meaning.

I understand the lyrics a lot better now and I listen to the song in a new light because of it. SO THANK YOU!

I'm happy to see you also loved 'What do you want me to do?" because I have had that song looping for ages. It's so much fun and the lyrics are funny in a black comedy kind of way. It totally reaches out to my eastern european roots lol. It's a shame so many people overlook it because of the style of the song but it's one of my favourites.

Again, you're amazing for doing this review. I bow down

Reply

o_srsly January 3 2011, 07:17:16 UTC
Nonono, don't you even think of buying me anything, because your tumblr is awesomer than any gift (well maybe other than giving me the boys themselves MUAHAHA) and seriously, the first place I check for GTOP news. :D So I bow down to you too

I enjoyed writing the Obsession and Of All Days parts the most, because they really consume my mind, and it felt good to lay it all out in words. I'm so flattered and honoured that you pimped me out on your tumblr dude, it's good to write something that helps. *HUG*

PS. To answer a thing you mentioned on your tumblr, I speak only Chinese and Japanese (other than English), but I also looked at some Japanese trans for Obsession.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up