Comments | pharnabazus: Narcissa Malfoy

pharnabazus

Narcissa Malfoy - more speculations

Jul 20, 2005 10:51

Comments 10

qem_chibati July 20 2005, 04:08:38 UTC

I personally thought Tonks behaved extremely dodgy throughout hbp, and I know I'm not the only one ( ... )

Dumbledore's alive qem_chibati July 20 2005, 12:47:21 UTC

I still think Dumbledore is alive. When he was buried, all we saw was flames and Harry thought he saw a phoenix. Do you think Dumbledore can transform into a pheonix?

fyrdrakken July 27 2005, 08:40:23 UTC

Really has me worried, because doesn't that imply that they don't change?

Don't have a copy of the book on me, and so far I've only had time to read it once, but I strongly recall someone (Lupin, perhaps) telling Harry that a Patronus can change if someone has a serious life-changing experience.

(The comment has been removed)

sodzilla July 20 2005, 22:10:35 UTC

But wasn't Andromeda on the outs with her family, after marrying a Muggleborn? I very much doubt that Narcissa could put her up to anything, much less a plot to replace (and presumably imprison or kill) her own daughter!

(The comment has been removed)

pharnabazus July 21 2005, 05:34:05 UTC

Yes, well, even I, with my liking for conspiracy theories and complicated hidden explanations, did find it hard to fully believe that Tonks was Narcissa (or anyone really) all the year round, tempted by the idea as I am! And yes, that comment more or less shoots down this part of the theory.

But I'm still not fully certain that the person who appeared so conveniently on the seventh floor when Harry had cornered Draco in the Room of Requirement neccessarily "was" Tonks - though I have to admit that she probably. But there still could be "some" twists! :-)

Thread 10