Also posted to goodkingnerdnor's response but wanted to make sure you read this.princesabinAugust 24 2008, 04:17:15 UTC
But I can say with some belief that Firefly while cut short was a good show and could stand alone. It's work can stand the test of time because even though it hadn't finished, our imagination and Serenity gave us some closure.
With Pirates of Dark Water Ren had found the living treasure of Rule, that stupid animal. Then it was done. That was it. It was a story that was very easy to measure: it would end with Ren getting all 13 Treasures of Rule. Or it would end with him failing.
It just ended. That's why I picked the Pirates of Dark Water over Firefly and another show I loved: Space: Above and Beyond.
Re: Also posted to goodkingnerdnor's response but wanted to make sure you read this.jackwabbitAugust 24 2008, 13:42:14 UTC
I can understand that. It's been so long since I've seen PODW that I didn't remember how it ended...only that I liked the show and it seems like most have forgotten it. With what you're saying, I can totally see your point.
I'm also posting this to the other guy's response tooprincesabinAugust 24 2008, 04:16:55 UTC
But I can say with some belief that Firefly while cut short was a good show and could stand alone. It's work can stand the test of time because even though it hadn't finished, our imagination and Serenity gave us some closure.
With Pirates of Dark Water Ren had found the living treasure of Rule, that stupid animal. Then it was done. That was it. It was a story that was very easy to measure: it would end with Ren getting all 13 Treasures of Rule. Or it would end with him failing.
It just ended. That's why I picked the Pirates of Dark Water over Firefly and another show I loved: Space: Above and Beyond.
Comments 7
Reply
Reply
With Pirates of Dark Water Ren had found the living treasure of Rule, that stupid animal. Then it was done. That was it. It was a story that was very easy to measure: it would end with Ren getting all 13 Treasures of Rule. Or it would end with him failing.
It just ended. That's why I picked the Pirates of Dark Water over Firefly and another show I loved: Space: Above and Beyond.
Reply
Reply
I think he got 8. And then the show ended.
Reply
I too voted Firefly, though.
Reply
With Pirates of Dark Water Ren had found the living treasure of Rule, that stupid animal. Then it was done. That was it. It was a story that was very easy to measure: it would end with Ren getting all 13 Treasures of Rule. Or it would end with him failing.
It just ended. That's why I picked the Pirates of Dark Water over Firefly and another show I loved: Space: Above and Beyond.
Reply
Leave a comment