potter potter potter potter....

Jul 24, 2007 14:27

Ha ha! Well, I didn't get The Book Friday at midnight, although I did swing by to check out the... madness ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 10

andreags July 24 2007, 19:47:48 UTC
Hahaha, yeah, I think this was a common complaint - the epilogue. PLUS, I couldn't keep track of the characters! Why oh why did they name them after Harry's dead parents?

Reply

spiffystuff July 24 2007, 19:56:07 UTC
Durrr, but that's what the end was all about! Naming the kids after dead characters! XD

I just finished The Book; I can certainly imagine that the epilogue is a source of consternation for many, but I haven't gone about reading opinions yet!

Reply


aintesduck July 24 2007, 20:34:42 UTC
One moment they're all collapsed together post-battle, we have an inkling that maybe understanding and relations will improve, then back to business as usual.

Sort of like real life.

That actually reminds me of an article I read years ago, a "one year later" follow-up piece on the first World Trade Center bombing. An interviewed person was saying how right after the bombing & evacuation lots of people who worked there were saying how they were going to keep in touch, how this experience was going to change their lives, how they were going to all have this bond because of their shared trauma, and all that sort of stuff - but how all that pretty much faded in a few weeks as things got back to normal.

Fact is, most traumatic events don't change most people's lives as much as you think they would.

Reply

derakon July 25 2007, 05:38:50 UTC
And to some extent, that's good - you're more likely to get post-traumatic stress disorder as a long-term effect from trauma than you are to get lifelong friends.

Still, that doesn't mean that we want to read about it! Epilogues are generally about making with the warm fuzzies, after all.

Reply

aintesduck July 25 2007, 13:27:31 UTC
you're more likely to get post-traumatic stress disorder as a long-term effect from trauma than you are to get lifelong friends.

Unfortunately far too true

Epilogues are generally about making with the warm fuzzies

I dunno, I always feel kind of cheated when I read a book or watch a movie that has a certain negative dramatic mood to it, and at the very end they tack on a happy ending; IMHO sort of trivializes everything that came before it in most cases.

Reply

derakon July 25 2007, 14:57:54 UTC
Well, yes, you have to pick when an epilogue is and isn't appropriate, ditto for the "surprise happy ending".

Reply


chyroptera July 25 2007, 21:04:48 UTC
The epilogue was wayyyyyyyy too much like a fanfic for me X.x

Reply

spiffystuff October 9 2007, 20:17:49 UTC
Hrm, now that I think about it, it really was, wasn't it?!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up