Comments | topfivelists: raised and regimented

reginalikestea in topfivelists

raised and regimented

Feb 28, 2005 22:20

Top Five Albums
1.Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy-Elton John
2.Bachelor No. 2 [or The Last Remains of the Dodo]-Aimee Mann
3.(Music from the motion picture) Garden State
4.The Smiths Best of...
5.Under the Tray-Reggie and the Full Effect

Comments 5

Or, how bout.... tshiverd March 1 2005, 13:49:15 UTC

1. Abbey Road - Beatles
2. No Fences - Garth Brooks
3. Out of the Blue - ELO
4. Wings over America - Wings
5. The Collection - Amy Grant

And actually I could never narrow it to five albums, but I like these a lot.

Re: Or, how bout.... reginalikestea March 2 2005, 03:50:34 UTC

You raised my eyebrow with the Garth...but I like your style. Brava.

thelonesoda March 1 2005, 20:13:09 UTC

Greatest Hits Albums aren't in place on top five lists. They already show the artists greatest work and make it unfair to the other candidates. That's just my opinion.

Greatest Hits Albums tshiverd March 2 2005, 03:57:03 UTC

I know and agree, but I was in a hurry and drawing a blank and the Collection is one of my all time favorites. And really for the same reason, I shouldn't include Wings over America because it is a live album and therefore just like a greatest hits album. I will redo it after I think about it for awhile. It is heavy pressure to narrow down all the albums of all time to five... Of course you could do the five greatest, greatest hits albums, now that would be a brain twister...

Re: Greatest Hits Albums thelonesoda March 2 2005, 04:25:05 UTC

Yeah... Good point with the top five... live.