Myth: How Far is Too Far?

[varkat]

An interesting question arose in the comments section of Rob Thurman’s guest blog a few weeks ago about how far a writer can take something from mythology away from its roots and still call it by its name of origin.  In other words, are vampires still vampires if they can walk about in the sunshine and don’t need to drink blood to survive.

I gave

Comments

[anonymous]

I like my myths to stick fairly close to traditional beliefs. If the writer can give me a logical explanation as to why the vampire doesn't need blood or can walk around in daylight, that's fine, but if they just start making things up for the sake of being different...sorry, don't call your creature a vampire. Vampires, zombies, werewolves...all are rooted in historical myths and legends and though there's always wriggle room, certain basic foundational beliefs should be followed.

Now when you're dealing with the fae, there are so many different kinds, a writer should have no problem finding one to suit their stories requirements.

Of course, this is just by personal opinion and no matter what someone writes, there are people who will love it.

[melenka]

I think having read a lot of mythology, I'm more flexible about what constitutes a particular type of paranormal creature. I don't mind vampires who don't drink blood, especially if they have other ways of draining and/or controlling humans. I don't need my therianthropes to have forced shifts with the moon, either. I rather like when canon is flipped around, as long as it comes with a good explanation about why everyone was mistaken about the way things are.

What I do insist upon is that the monsters have some vulnerability or disadvantage that gives humans a chance to prevail, whether in combat or love. I have serious concerns about people who fall in love with those who consider them food.

[varkat]

Totally agree! We all have weaknesses, and those supernaturally gifted should be preternaturally vulnerable. It's only fair. Plus, there's no tension if there's no real question of who will win any given cage match.