Poll

Ok, I know this is a little off-topic, but I have to tell someone.

I guess everybody heard about this, right? Since I heard, I’ve been dying to say I TOLD YOU SO to the world in general. Not add another word, my ass. Of course she was going to write more ( Read more... )

Okay, HP can't be the only fandom we occupy, and it's been a while since anything's been posted, so I decided to revv up a new discussion.

Now I'll admit, there are still things I love about HP and the fandom (those genuinely good parts of the books I can't let go of, really good people to chat up with, non-canon fanfiction, and a few other things ( Read more... )

Okay, we all know that the writing quality of HP, especially in HBP and DH, was full of mistakes so painful, they're almost unmentionable. But have they inspired your own writings in some inverse way?

For me, it has.

- When I'm writing a new plot twist/development, I will always ask myself, “What purpose will this serve to the story as a whole?” If ( Read more... )

You know how a lot of random facts got into the movies and the fans kept saying that everything would be explained at the end ( Read more... )

If anyone's interested, some people have been taking DH apart chapter-by-chapter here:
( Read more... )

Do I hate the Crapilogue?

Yes, yes I do.

Why I do...

1. There was no true sense of closure and the important questions we wanted answered weren’t getting answered. What about the old storyline of house unity and full acceptance of people no matter what Hogwarts House they are in or their bloodlines? What about equality for all non-human species like ( Read more... )

OK. So now apparently JKR has said in an interview that Dumbledore/Grindelwald is canon. Someone reads WAY too much fanfic ;)

However, if this is what she intended, then why not make it explicit in the books? Why do all the characters describe it as a 'friendship'? Are they all homophobic or something?

What are the dropped plot points in DH that annoyed you the most? Or what turned out to have been completely pointless?

( Here are some of mine )

I hope this isn't too off topic, but ( Read more... )