[ Round Two ] Challenge 01 | Results

[trickle]

Let me get things straight :/
I said I would be strict about voting and I'm not joking. Some of you didn't read the voting guidelines. I'm fine with notifying you guys if you need to elaborate more on your voting but not voting when I've said that all participants should vote to avoid disqualification just bothers me

Comments

[anonymous]

[trickle]

LEAST QUALITY VOTES;- The text choice does not support the icon well. It feels generic for Halloween's sake more than having to do with the icon. Maybe a different text choice, or even no text (it still looks quite creepy/Halloweenish, though I'm not sure if it would have passed the mod. ^^; It's not a terrible icon, just a lesser quality

[anonymous]

[trickle]

LEAST QUALITY VOTES;- The image of Gatomon is too dark, althought the theme was to have black in the icon, the image could have been brightened up whilst the background stayed black. The textures give a bit of colour but it doesn't seem in the right position, if it was placed on Gatomon, it may have looked much better. The unreadable text is a nice touch but if there was some readable text, viewers would be able to know what is precisely going on in the icon

[anonymous]

[trickle]

LEAST QUALITY VOTES;
- The idea behind the icon is creative for the theme, but the coloring just doesn't mix well. The exclusion layer is too obvious and gives the vibrant pinks and greens a kind of bland yellow coloring. And that doesn't really look good against the background of BlackTyrannomon. My only suggestion is a better crop (more negative space with the sky OR BlackTyrannomon's body) and to maybe lower the opacity of the exclusion layer because it just looks too 'yellow'.
- The colouring is good, I must say. But it seems a little too dark for the subject, the crop could have been tighter in order to focus more on her.

SPECIAL CATEGORY - BEST COLOURING VOTES;
- The coloring is amazing. Lillymon's beauty really comes out.

[anonymous]

[trickle]

I regret having to eliminate you and I understand how real life can interfere with online stuff. Just a piece of advice if you participate in other rounds, you can just comment with an explanation that you won't be able to vote if you're busy and such, since results can be delayed a few hours, I would have given time for others who have not voted to vote.

FAVOURITE VOTES;- Very nice cropping and text placement. The colors work well to with the character you chose to icon

[anonymous]

[trickle]

LEAST QUALITY VOTES;
- Cropping is nice, but the crest sign is throwing the icon a tad bit off. the maker could change the color of the sign, or remove it (:

FAVOURITE VOTES;
- It's a bright, vivid icon that doesn't take anything away from the subject. Great job!