Hello, everyone who still happens to be watching this comm! It's been a while!

Recently fauxkaren and I have been talking about possibly resuscitating this comm sometime soon. Before we start going around promoting, though, I figured it might be a good idea to get some feedback from the people who were around last time, if any of you care to oblige ( Read more... )

I hope this is okay to post here, but if not, please feel free to delete it! But since this seems like a fairly active community (and since it's specifically aimed at episodic rewatches, which might also yield important opinions on how people's opinions have changed/evolved on the following topic), I thought it might provide quality material for my ( Read more... )

SO here is the final cage match poll, based on the winners for the cage match polls for each season & the specials.

Poll Most of these were pretty clear-cut, except s3 which was one vote away from being a 3-way tie (runners-up being Human Nature/Family of Blood and Blink). S5 was probably the biggest margin, with Vincent & The Doctor winning by an ( Read more... )

:O Our last discussion post! Crazy. The cage match poll will go up soon. But first... the creatively-named A Christmas Carol!


( Read more... )

So it's Wednesday which means we should be on A Christmas Carol, but the TPO/TBB post was so late (...er...) that I'm just going to do the s5 poll instead and Christmas Carol I'll put up later this week. I tagged Christmas Carol into the poll already though because it does not fit elsewhere.

Poll

Okay this is definitely behind schedule, but omg now we're done s5!


( Read more... )

Omg we're almost done! And this post is late, sorry. In 5x11, The Lodger, we see the weirdest set dressing of all time:


( Read more... )

So in Vincent and the Doctor we get another historical figure, the BBC saves on CGI, and Bill Nighy gets the eternal glory of being the first person to be in all three of Harry Potter, Love Actually and Doctor Who.


( Read more... )

Okay bear with me, The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood are kind of... well they are my least favourite episodes in the entirety of New Who. Sooo... yeah. I will do my best to make fair questions though.


( Read more... )

With a bit of delay we hit my favourite episode of s5, Amy's Choice. In which Amy has an imaginary baby, Rory has a ponytail, the Doctor has some issues with self-loathing, and everyone wears ponchos.


( Read more... )