About Harry Burn

Feb 07, 2011 17:16

[Stylistic commentary welcome. The story is true, and pretty wonderful ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 13

dac February 8 2011, 03:27:54 UTC
I don't understand. He changed his mind?

Reply

lemonmerchant February 8 2011, 04:22:08 UTC
Indeed. He switched from "no" to "yes".

Good call, though. I'll change the ending a bit to try to make it clearer.

Reply

dac February 8 2011, 04:24:47 UTC
nice. Is the flower some sort of foreshadowing of his feminine sympathy?

Reply

lemonmerchant February 8 2011, 04:34:37 UTC
No, the red rose was what the anti-suffragists wore.

Reading comprehension, sir, reading comprehension.

*tsk* *knuckle-rap*

Reply


chaerm February 8 2011, 08:30:13 UTC

I've often wondered if you've missed your calling as a writer. I certainly appreciate your style, although, is this the beginning middle, and end or just the start of something greater? I would recommend that if this is all there is to be then consider revising the last sentence only from the world being a different place by the time he went to sleep. I feel that it doesn't fit well stylistically with the rest of the story. It's almost as if the author changed...I can't quite put my finger on it. Otherwise, beautifully done.

Reply

lemonmerchant February 8 2011, 17:58:07 UTC
I had a rough feeling about that final sentence, too, and have since reworked the last bit entirely.

This would be the start of a chapter, probably.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

lemonmerchant February 8 2011, 18:09:08 UTC
Thanks. It is, as you say, intended as the beginning of a chapter.

I am still not wholly satisfied with the last sentence, but that may have to stay as it is for now. Ultimately, it would need to connect to the paragraph that follows it. But since I don't now what that paragraph looks like, it's sort of like making a plug, for a socket whose shape and size you don't know.

Reply


reasie February 8 2011, 18:22:56 UTC
NICE! I see from other comments that you've tweaked since original posting, so I'm commenting on the edited version but I found it both well-paced and clear. I like the double-barrel hit of the climax of the story just at the end. :)

Reply

lemonmerchant February 8 2011, 20:36:37 UTC
Thanks. The ending will certainly want for some tweaking, if and when there is a next paragraph, to facilitate the broadening of scope.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up