Leave a comment

Comments 14

_allshallfade August 17 2005, 02:54:58 UTC
No. You didn't answer why to a few questions. And, even for the ones you did, the answers weren't very thorough.

Reply


thekatester August 17 2005, 03:29:11 UTC
Your application was pretty short, so I'll go with no on it for the time being... But please, apply again in a month or so, I'd love to read your reasoning for some of your answers!

PS. "Concerning Hobbits" rocks, therefore you also rock.

Reply


hckyboy00 August 17 2005, 03:46:13 UTC
No. I don't even see a shadow of promise concerning a worthy application in the future in this.

Reply

feylin17 August 17 2005, 15:50:11 UTC
hey now, lets not be harsh. People can reapply if we all vote no and they fix things up satisfactorily. :)

Reply


annebloom188 August 17 2005, 04:10:41 UTC
No
For reasons already stated above and then some.

Reply


nesmith August 17 2005, 07:32:39 UTC
No. Not least of which for "Gandaulf" and "Silmarilian"?? It takes but a few seconds to spell names correctly.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up