Random Fandom Question: Vogler vs. Tritter?

Jun 30, 2013 13:26

Which House villian did you dislike more ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 26

cuddyclothes June 30 2013, 17:39:34 UTC
To me, Vogler was a cardboard character that they wrote in to provide a conflict in the season. Wilson stood up for House, but the whole thing...you know House won't get fired.

Tritter, on the other hand, had a personal vendetta (you know someone in his life was a drug addict). Although a lot of what he did on the show would have never happened in real life (taking over an empty office, looking through records without a warrant, not having a supervising officer), it happened on the show. What House was put through, between Tritter being an evil sonavabitch and House's own refusal to be reasonable, was awful. I was so glad when House yelled, "You sonavabitch!" I also LOVED the scene when Cuddy explodes at House when he's in jail.

Also, I've never know if House's apology to Wilson was sincere.

Reply

petitecuriosity July 1 2013, 17:37:40 UTC
Tritter, on the other hand, had a personal vendetta (you know someone in his life was a drug addict).

What House was put through, between Tritter being an evil sonavabitch and House's own refusal to be reasonable, was awful.

Oh I definitely agree with you here. There is a part of me that wants to read fic about whomever Tritter knew was a drug addict. My guess would be a sibling.

I also enjoyed Cuddy's explosion at House. She was badass in that scene.

I wasn't sure whether House's apology to Wilson was sincere or not either. Well, at the time I thought it was, due to the reluctance in House's delivery that didn't seem to be put on, and, as Wilson said, it wasn't necessary to House's plan. Why do you think it might not have been sincere? Perhaps so that Wilson would be so caught off guard that he wouldn't suspect what House was up to with "Voldemort"?

Reply


violettblack June 30 2013, 18:47:18 UTC
Tritter, because of the reasons you already mentioned.

Reply

petitecuriosity July 1 2013, 17:37:54 UTC
He truly is slimy, isn't he?

Reply


lieueitak June 30 2013, 20:53:51 UTC
I don't particularly dislike either, as much as I dislike the effect they had on House's colleagues' behavior. Wilson and Cuddy were pretty unbearable during the Tritter arc IMO. However, if I had to pick one character I disliked more, it would be Vogler who seemed to want obedience for its own sake and not because it would benefit the hospital in any way ( ... )

Reply

petitecuriosity July 1 2013, 17:40:02 UTC
Thank you for your interesting insights!

I can understand what you mean with regard to Tritter's motivations being more understandable than Vogler's. I do think that Vogler's was more power driven, obedience for its own sake, as you say, whereas Tritter's seemed more to be based in revenge for House's cruel actions.

Reply


hughville June 30 2013, 22:12:21 UTC
Vogler wanted to do something good to honor his father who had Alzheimer's Disease. The problem with Vogler was that he was a businessman and tried to run the hospital like a business and wanted to use patients in his drug trials. I thought Vogler and House were similar in that Vogler's dad gave him money for college. Vogler took the money and invested it in a company so he defied his father (didn't follow the rules) and became a huge success. House took great delight in breaking rules ( ... )

Reply

chocolate_frapp July 1 2013, 04:36:31 UTC
Somewhat OT but I've been watching a miniseries about John Adams that has David Morse playing George Washington of all people.

Reply

petitecuriosity July 1 2013, 17:45:22 UTC
Wow, after seeing him as Tritter, I find that to be a bit amusing. Is it a good miniseries?

Reply

chocolate_frapp July 2 2013, 15:05:25 UTC
yes, it is. The acting is excellent.

Reply


flywoman July 1 2013, 00:40:44 UTC
I thought that Tritter was actually more sympathetic than Vogler in many ways (but that's probably because I don't admire businessmen). He is the Javert of the House universe. He was trying to put someone away that he believed to be dangerous and became obsessed with that goal. He was, imo, JUST LIKE HOUSE in his willingness to do whatever it took to win (put away a criminal vs. save a patient).

Reply

cuddyclothes July 1 2013, 03:37:31 UTC
But-but-Vogler had such a weird-shaped head! He had the SKULL OF DOOM.

Reply

flywoman July 1 2013, 11:29:24 UTC
LOL. Well, maybe that contributes to my dislike of him.

Reply

petitecuriosity July 1 2013, 17:48:21 UTC
LOL. XD.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up